Wisconsin State Supreme Court shapes recusal standards.

Byline: Jack Zemlicka

Campaign donations alone will not necessitate that a judge step down from a case involving a contributor.

So said the Wisconsin State Supreme Court, which granted two rules petitions on Oct. 28 that modify the Judicial Code of Conduct to state that money received from a campaign supporter cannot be the sole reason for recusal.

The 4-3 ruling was the culmination of a lengthy debate by the court on four petitions, two of which sought to establish contribution caps of $1,000 and $10,000 per person to trigger automatic recusal.

Ultimately, the court decided to maintain the status quo, said attorney Thomas J. Basting, Sr., who attended the hearing.

The Wisconsin Realtor's Association (WRA) and Wisconsin Manufacturers & Commerce (WMC) proposed the petitions that were ultimately adopted. Both the petitioners argued that placing limits on contributions and mandating recusal would infringe on free speech rights.

What happened is the court invited big money contributions and third party advocates to spend as much money as they can in judicial elections, complained Basting, who chairs the campaign watchdog group, the Wisconsin Judicial Campaign Integrity Committee.

While the ruling basically codified current practice, Basting said it now gives a judge or justice an out to not have to step down from a case involving an individual or business which may have contributed significantly to his or her campaign.

And that will make it harder for some litigants to feel as if they are getting a fair shake from the court, suggested Justice Ann Walsh Bradley, who voted in the minority.

She was joined by Chief Justice Shirley S. Abrahamson and Justice N. Patrick Crooks.

Ethics attorney Daniel L. Shneidman, who attended a portion of the hearing, suggested that lawyers will now wonder who's got the judge in their back pocket.

But Justice Michael J...

To continue reading

Request your trial

VLEX uses login cookies to provide you with a better browsing experience. If you click on 'Accept' or continue browsing this site we consider that you accept our cookie policy. ACCEPT