The Giving Tree.

AuthorCousin, Ertharin
PositionBook review

THE GIVING TREE. By Shel Silverstein. New York, Evanston, and London: Harper & Row. 1964. (Harper Collins Publishers 50th Anniversary 2014 ed.). P. 55. $16.99.

INTRODUCTION

For fifty years, The Giving Tree, a short illustrated tale revered by adults and loved by children, has provoked outrage and acclaim in equal measure. (1) Some readers disliked the story so much that they wrote an alternative ending, while others celebrated it as a modern-day parable. Described by its author, Shel Silverstein, as a simple story of a relationship between two people, (2) The Giving Tree reads like a children's book while offering much food for thought. Since the initial publication, scholars, students, and many others have offered a variety of interpretations and critiques of this short yet provocative work, calling into question not only how women (metaphorically), men, and children interact but also how we as a global society decide to manage our future.

Silverstein, like me, was born in Chicago. (3) And like many Chicagoans, Silverstein did not believe in sugarcoating the truth. His motivations become evident when reading his illustrations, books, and poems, as well as when listening to his songs. He spent his career unearthing humanity's universal truths and values, even its most uncomfortable ones. In doing so, Silverstein offers readers young and old an opportunity for reflection and self-critique.

Written in 1960 and eventually published in 1964, The Giving Tree was a product of this turbulent period. A man of his time, Silverstein did not believe in cookie-cutter, happily-ever-after stories--especially for children. It took him several years to find a publisher willing to break the mold. (4) In a rare New York Times interview, the unconventional author stated his conviction that happy endings, magical solutions, and mythic heroes serve to alienate children by establishing impossible burdens and expectations that can never be met. (5) The candid, even cruel, simplicity of The Giving Tree exemplifies Silverstein's parental logic.

The first time I encountered The Giving Tree, my grandson actually did most of the reading. He enjoyed the pictures, understood the plot, and finished the book with a smile. He understood that the tree was happy, even though she was left with nothing, save for the love and company of the boy. We enjoyed this story on our first reading; even for a six-year-old child, the book raised so many questions. It demands rereading, again and again.

For me, the story raised questions, much like a modern-day parable of life. Silverstein's prose gave me pause for thought. I reflected on its lessons, of course for children, but also for myself as a parent, a grandparent, a lawyer, and as the head of the United Nations World Food Programme ("WFP"). I concluded that The Giving Tree is primarily a fable about the imperfect nature of human relations. It speaks of the consequences of when we fail to uphold our duty of care to one another, despite our best--even loving--intentions.

  1. THE GIVING TREE: A SUMMARY

    The story begins with a tree, a universal source of refuge and strength (p. 4). The imagery of the tree embodies a sense of stability but also of renewal and cyclical growth. Every new leaf is a symbol of vitality and perennial life.

    Naturally, the central character of The Giving Tree is not an ordinary tree. The tree is personified; it is introduced to us as a she and given emotions to love a little boy (p. 6). The book's illustrations, central throughout the story, animate the loving relationship between the tree and the boy (pp. 8-17). The tree virtually bends its branches to reach out and shelter the boy, while the boy runs gleefully to spend time with the tree every day (pp. 8-9). He collects her leaves, makes shapes with them, and plays games with her (pp. 10-13). We believe he is happy. For her part, the tree is happy to have fun with and care for the boy (p. 27). There is a whimsical and simple interaction between the boy and the tree, an interaction that seems founded on unconditional love.

    The loving relationship between the boy and the tree is reciprocal (pp. 24-27). It appears that it will last forever. The tree has a lot to offer the boy, and she makes him very happy (pp. 10-27). The tree also loves the boy's company, even allowing him to carve a love heart into her trunk with the engraving "Me + T" (p. 26). We are led to believe that the tree is the boy's first love.

    Their relationship is symbiotic, and, for a time, the mutual bond works (pp. 26-33). As the boy matures, however, his needs and thoughts develop. He finds a second love, and he brings her to the tree. He even carves a second love heart into the tree's bark, engraving the initials "Me + Y.L." (p. 30). The boy abandons the tree in favor of his new love, often leaving the tree alone (p. 33).

    Sometime later, the boy returns (pp. 34-37). The tree invites him to play, to eat her apples, and to be happy (p. 34). The boy is now an adolescent (pp. 34-35), and he tells the tree that he has outgrown such things and that instead he wants money to buy things and have fun (p. 34). She offers the boy her apples, advising him to go and sell them in the city and to use the proceeds to be happy (p. 34). The boy accepts this offer and climbs the tree to remove her apples (pp. 36-37). He again departs, and in that moment the tree is happy (p. 37).

    The tree is left alone for a long time, until one day when the adolescent boy returns as a man (pp. 38-39). Once again, the tree is thrilled (p. 38). She again invites the boy to play and to be happy (p. 38). But once again, he refuses (p. 39). This time he is too busy with plans--plans to build a house and a family of his own (p. 39). For a second time, he asks the tree for something she seemingly cannot provide--a house (p. 39). She encourages the boy to cut her branches and to use them to build a house so he can be happy (p. 39). Once more, the boy accepts the tree's offer (p. 40). He cuts down all the branches he can carry (pp. 40-41), and the tree is again happy, even though she has been denuded of her once productive and giving branches (p. 43).

    Once more, the boy stays away a long time, eventually returning as an old man (p. 44). The tree is beside herself with joy, and she invites him to come and play with her (p. 44). The boy tells her that he is too old and too sad and that he wants a boat to go far, far away (p. 44). Of course, the tree has a solution for the boy. She offers him her trunk, inviting him to chop it down and to use it to make a boat (p. 45). The boy accepts, cutting her trunk between...

To continue reading

Request your trial

VLEX uses login cookies to provide you with a better browsing experience. If you click on 'Accept' or continue browsing this site we consider that you accept our cookie policy. ACCEPT