The Fine Art of Camouflage: Migrant-Drug Distributors Negotiating Police Interactions in Switzerland

Published date01 September 2023
DOIhttp://doi.org/10.1177/00027162241248998
AuthorLouis Vuilleumier
Date01 September 2023
ANNALS, AAPSS, 709, September 2023 165
DOI: 10.1177/00027162241248998
The Fine Art of
Camouflage:
Migrant-Drug
Distributors
Negotiating
Police
Interactions in
Switzerland
By
LOUIS VUILLEUMIER
1248998ANN THE ANNALS OF THE AMERICAN ACADEMYTHE FINE ART OF CAMOUFLAGE
research-article2024
Bogged down in exploitative jobs or unemployment,
some migrants mitigate their precarious condition and
forced idleness through involvement in petty crime,
including low-level drug distribution. This article
explores the daily lives of migrants who navigate asym-
metrical interactions and relationships with police in
ways that avoid detection of their illicit activities.
Drawing from extensive ethnographic fieldwork and 18
biographical interviews with sub-Saharan male migrants
active in low-level drug retail, I scrutinize how migrants
negotiate the rules that are supposed to govern them. I
am particularly interested in the ways in which migrants
negotiate their legal status with the police, whose view
of them is often heavily influenced by race. I demon-
strate that relationships between police officers and
migrants can be influenced by migrants’ deliberate
mimicry of local norms, calculated conformity with
informal policing practices, and influence over police
officers’ moral judgment of whether they are deserving
of police’s discretionary power to look the other way.
Keywords: drug trafficking; migration; racial profil-
ing; discretion; cop wisdom; illegibility;
Switzerland
On a sunny afternoon, I went window-shop-
ping in the city center of Beauregard, an
anonymous Swiss city.1 Along the way, I met
three acquaintances who had just finished
lunch at a local African restaurant, taking a
break from their work as street drug distribu-
tors. They invited me for a drink, and since I
had free time, I happily joined them. We
opened some beers in front of a supermarket
and started to chitchat. Suddenly, two police
Correspondence: louis.vuilleumier@unifr.ch
Louis Vuilleumier is a PhD candidate in the Institute of
Social Anthropology at the University of Fribourg
(Switzerland). His research focuses on the temporal,
material, and moral dimensions of European mobility
regimes, the effects of migratory policies on the trajec-
tories of illegalized migrants, and their ways of negoti-
ating the rules that are supposed to govern them.
166 THE ANNALS OF THE AMERICAN ACADEMY
officers on bicycles appeared and asked everyone but me for identification docu-
ments (ID). The three of them were Black male migrants; I and the two officers
were white male citizens. When I asked what the purpose of this police check
was, one of the police officers replied, “You obviously know who those guys are,
they are not tourists.” Noticing the silence and docility of my three acquaint-
ances, I did not insist, despite the legal obligation for the police to provide a clear
explanation for such a measure. After checking their documents, the officers
instructed us to move on, despite the fact that one of the police officers explained
that Issa, a 30-year-old sub-Saharan migrant, had overstayed his visa and was now
considered “illegal.” Before we separated, Issa disclosed to me, “One of those
cops, we call him Mepton. He doesn’t care much about your documents. You just
have to play it regular, play it square and he [will] let you be.”2 Apparently, they
seemed to know each other.
This kind of humiliating experience is a recurrent one for “illegalized”
migrants.3 What is striking about this scene is how it captures not only the entan-
glement of mobility regimes and everyday policing, public disorder, and social
ordering, but also the subtle strategies migrants use to manage face-to-face
encounters with state representatives. Reinforcing discriminatory power dynam-
ics, European mobility regimes facilitate the mobility of some—the so-called
global citizens and highly skilled migrants—while fettering the movement of
others (Glick Schiller and Salazar 2013). This perpetuates a (post)colonial and
racialized filtering process (van Houtum 2010). Representations of the “deviant
immigrant” (Melossi 2003), both criminal and alien, frame them as putting
unbearable pressure on welfare systems and posing a threat to the ostensible
national order. This sorting mechanism creates different groupings of migrants
assigned varying degrees of status that translate into differential access to labor
markets and mobility within Europe.
For the migrants, illegalization translates into a constant threat of detention
and deportation (De Genova 2002; Khosravi 2010), which can upend their rela-
tionship to time, space, and self (Andersson 2014; Willen 2007). Fear becomes a
part of the everyday life of these migrants, instilling in them a deep sense of
discretion and a need to seek refuge in hiding (Bjørneseth 2017; Le Courant
2022; Madsen 2004). Moreover, the racialization of migrants plays a crucial role
in shaping the experiences and treatment of individuals labeled as “illegal aliens.”
Since the perception of migrants as illegal is not based solely on legal status but
is deeply rooted in racial and ethnic categorizations (De Genova 2002), racial
profiling is seen as an effective tool for detecting those who have violated a state’s
sovereignty and subjects them to increased forms of surveillance, scrutiny, and
potential deportation. Indeed, racial profiling exacerbated the racialization pro-
cess by disproportionately targeting individuals based on their perceived and
ascribed race, ethnicity, or religion (Harris 2002), which leads to the overrepre-
sentation of certain racial and ethnic groups in migration raids, detentions, and
deportations, as well as in drug law enforcement actions.
Trapped in seemingly endless periods of unemployment or exploitative work,
some migrants mitigate their precarious condition and forced idleness through
their involvement in petty crime, including low-level drug distribution.4 However,

To continue reading

Request your trial

VLEX uses login cookies to provide you with a better browsing experience. If you click on 'Accept' or continue browsing this site we consider that you accept our cookie policy. ACCEPT