The dragon and the elephant.

• Author: Zhongying, Pang
• Position: Debating Delhi - Critical essay

THERE IS a near-pathological obsession in China with the question of what defines a "rising power" (da guo jue qi). Last year, China's Central Television created and broadcasted a twelve-episode series ("Da Guo Jue Qi") that analyzed the rise of nine of the great powers of the modern era, from Spain and Portugal in the 15th century through to Great Britain, the United States and Japan. The implications of this program were clear: China wants to achieve its long-held aspiration of becoming a global power, and it is consciously taking as its models the developed states of the West. But the other rising power of the 21st century, India, is rarely discussed as a model for China's own rise. For some of China's strategic thinkers, India is not China's peer as a major power in today's world or as a potential great power of the future.

This is ironic, given that India was China's first exposure to the West. More than 1,300 years ago, the Buddhist monk Xuanzang (602-664) conducted his famed "Journey to the West" to bring classic Buddhist and Sanskrit texts to the then--Chinese capital at Xi'an. And today, Xuanzang's latter-day disciples--in this case investors, not monks--are again making the pilgrimage to India, especially to New Delhi, Mumbai and Bangalore.

When India does figure into the calculations of China's strategic planners, they see India's rise as a challenge, as the latest in a series of powers on the country's periphery with an eye towards encircling the Middle Kingdom. For the first half of the twentieth century, China had to deal with another Westernizing rising power, Japan, which was not only hostile to Beijing but ended up invading and occupying parts of China in pursuit of regional dominance. Now, on China's southern and western periphery, looms "Asia's elephant." In 2004, then-Prime Minister Atal Bihari Vajpayee announced a "twenty-year plan" for India to attain great-power status. However, with its nuclear arsenal and its naval capabilities, India's geopolitical influence is already beginning to extend far beyond its traditional limits of the subcontinent.

A number of observers both within China and around the world believe that, for the foreseeable future, China will continue to have the advantage over India. This may be true, but India should not be discounted. India's rise may be slower than that of China, but it is no less real. Whereas much of China's growth has been fueled by foreign direct investment, India can point to...