Technology and choice.

PositionAbortion and pre-natal screen ethics - Editorial

Advances in reproductive technology do not necessarily mean greater reproductive freedom for individuals around the globe. The most obvious example of this is in China, where the government recently announced a chilling plan to use fetal testing, forced sterilization, abortion, and a ban on marriages between people with congenital illnesses to weed out "new births of inferior quality."

While China - long criticized by the rest of the world for its coercive birth-control policies - has now bowed to international pressure to temper its plan, state interference in citizens' reproduction is a serious concern in the West as well.

In the United States, after fetal tests showed that twenty-two-year-old Tabita Bricci's baby might not be getting enough oxygen, the pregnant woman found herself in a Cook County courtroom, facing a court-appointed attorney for her unborn fetus. County officials argued that the woman should be forced to follow her doctors' orders to undergo a Cesarean section - which she had refused for religious and personal reasons - for the sake of her baby's health.

The case, which reached the U.S. Supreme Court, was overtaken by events when the woman gave birth to an apparently healthy baby in December. But it would have been an appalling illustration of the state's coercive power had the prosecutor's office prevailed, restraining Bricci all the way to the operating table.

That sort of coercive government intervention in people's bodies, whether for the sake of eliminating "undesirables," controlling population, or protecting "fetal rights" is an intolerable violation of individual freedom.

The same principle applies in Europe, where public furor over a fifty-nine-year-old English woman who gave birth to twins prompted officials in France and Italy to propose legislation forbidding women from using medical technology to become pregnant after menopause. "To have a...

To continue reading

Request your trial

VLEX uses login cookies to provide you with a better browsing experience. If you click on 'Accept' or continue browsing this site we consider that you accept our cookie policy. ACCEPT