Surfing Secrets.

• Author: DePalma, Jennifer
• Position: Review

The multiple meanings of online privacy

The Hundredth Window: Protecting Your Privacy and Security in the Age of the Internet, by Charles Jennings and Lori Fena, New York: The Free Press, 278 pages, $26

Internet privacy isn't just one debate, it's several. One involves how much information an e-business should be allowed to require of its customers, and what it should be allowed to do with the data it collects. (Does a Web site, say, have the right to pass data along to third parties?) Another debate centers around when the government should have access to information shared online. Then there's online anonymity: Should people be allowed to post e-mails or Web pages under false names? What should be the legal repercussions of giving a site false information?

And don't forget things like firewalls that protect sites from unwanted visitors and encryption tools that keep data and information top secret. The police want to be able to search networks for illegal activity (gambling, child pornography, hacking, etc.). They therefore dislike the idea of strong encryption--or would at least like a guaranteed means of breaking that encryption should the need arise. But weaker encryption increases the chances that your privacy will be violated-that someone else will get access to the information you transmit online.

It's an important set of arguments. Many people understandably dislike the thought of corporations or the government amassing detailed profiles of them: Even if the profile keepers have the best of intentions, there's still the possibility of stolen identity or wrongful accusation. How receptive consumers are to e-commerce depends on how secure they feel using it. On the other hand, such information is valuable to companies: It helps them learn what their consumers want and improve their products.

It sounds like a tangle, but there's a straightforward thread that runs through all of these questions: how best to balance economic and technological improvement with freedom and personal space. Yet the debates often cloud this basic concern by spinning worst-case scenarios as though they were commonplace. Hyperbole, wild generalizations, and outlandish predictions about the possible uses and likely abuses of information are common. Few authors present the facts and lay out the issues in a way that lets laypeople develop an informed opinion, deciding for themselves what potential dangers are lurking.

The Hundredth Window is, for the most part...