Still a Chill in the Air.

• Author: Rothschild, Matthew
• Position: Essay

[ILLUSTRATION OMITTED]

ALMOST SINCE 9/12, I'VE BEEN COVERING INFRINGEMENTS ON OUR CIVIL LIBERTIES, ESPECIALLY AS THEY AFFECT PEOPLE IN THEIR DAY-TO-DAY LIVES. I first wrote about it in a cover story for The Progressive entitled "The New McCarthyism" back in January 2002. I've followed up periodically in these pages. And for our website, progressive.org, I've written more than 200 such stories. I'm still writing them today, even though there has been something of a cultural thaw. Bill Maher is back on cable. The Dixie Chicks, who once faced mass hostility, including bonfires of their CDs, have enjoyed renewed popularity on the charts and at the Grammys. Other musicians, across genres, have spoken out against the Bush Administration at no cost. Keith Olbermann on MSNBC denounces the President, and gets a larger audience for it. Jon Stewart regularly skewers Bush, as does David Letterman. And Stephen Colbert memorably spoofed the President of the United States to his face at the 2006 White House Correspondents' Dinner.

In communities across the country, there also appears to be some more space for dissent. When Lisa Jensen and Bill Trimarco of Loma Linda, Colorado, put up a Christmas wreath in the shape of a peace symbol on their house in November 2006, they were threatened by the Loma Linda Homeowners Association with a $25-a-day fine. But the local outcry was so fierce that the board members of the homeowners association had to back down, apologize, and resign. Other residents nearby began putting up their own peace wreaths in solidarity.

But not everyone has been able to escape the sting of repression. And for Arabs and Muslims in the United States, the climate is as cold as ever. At the same time that the Loma Linda residents rose up to defend their free speech rights, for instance, six imams were handcuffed and booted off a US Airways flight in Minneapolis after complaints that they were praying before boarding. The harassment of Arabs and Muslims continues in myriad ways.

And don't get me wrong: Some dissenters are not yet free to speak without fearing the consequences. In May, CBS yanked retired Army Major General John Batiste off the air as a consultant after he appeared in a TV ad denouncing Bush's failed strategy in Iraq.

Here are three recent stories that give you a sense of the temperature today in America, almost six years after 9/11.

M ichael Baker taught in the Lincoln, Nebraska, public school system since 1981. But after he showed the HBO documentary Baghdad ER to his East High School geography class on April 18, his career there was over.

This, despite the fact that in 2006, Baker was one of only forty-seven teachers in the state to win National Board Certification, according to the Lincoln Journal Star , which broke the story.

Baker tells me he cannot talk freely about what happened because he reached an agreement with the school district. Part of that agreement prohibits him from saying much about it, he says.

But he does acknowledge this: "The morning after I showed the documentary Baghdad ER was my last day in class."

HBO says Baghdad ER captures "the humanity, hardships, and heroism of the U.S. Military and medical personnel of the 86th Combat Support Hospital." Even the National Review sung its praises, calling it "refreshingly earnest."

Baker carefully frames his departure. "Teachers that teach against the grain often have difficulties with school systems," he says. "What has happened to me is certainly not unusual."

His supporters are not so circumspect.

Michael Anderson taught with Baker at East High School for eight years. Now he's the director of the School of Education at the University of Wisconsin at Platteville.

"It's outrageous," Anderson says of Baker's departure.

"I believe there were students who went home and were troubled about what they saw, and there were parental phone calls to the principal, and the next day she walked him out the door because she didn't have the courage to stand up to the complainers," he says. Anderson says Baker was first suspended for ten days with pay and then "got the lawyers involved."

Anderson thinks that the administrators seized on this incident to get rid of Baker.

"What's obvious is that...