Rethinking Europe.

Charles Kupchan's thoughts on Europe, well argued as they are, beg several questions ("Rethinking Europe", Summer 1999). First, what kind of regional organization would NATO remain if it were able to intervene in any crisis bordering, let's say, China, Iran or Greece? Would it become the UN's iron fist? Or would the Security Council become NATO's puppy? Second, who would have the guts to offer Russia the prominence inside the alliance it would then demand? Among other things, Russia would digest NATO's budget. And are NATO countries really prepared to trust Russia? What guarantees do we have that Russia will not play dirty in moments of crisis? Finally, what assurance is there that the reforms in Russia will go forward to a successful conclusion?

When we have concrete answers to these questions, I shall be prepared to give Kupchan's idea a second thought. But until then, the best that can be hoped for is amicable relations between NATO and Russia.

Viorel Andrievici

Sibiu, Romania

Kupchan replies

Viorel Andrievici worries that if NATO continues to expand eastward and includes Russia, the alliance might become too powerful and wide-ranging, at times overshadowing the UN and acting...