Rebuilding the Gulf Coast: the high rates of property insurance in the post-Katrina era has made rebuilding difficult.

• Author: Boulard, Garry

When Brian Sanderson surveys the endless number of vacant lots along the Mississippi Gulf coast nearly two years after Hurricane Katrina, he is struck by how much remains to be done.

"Building is going on up and down the coast," says Sanderson, who is the president of the Gulf Coast Business Council in Gulfport, Miss. "But there could be so much more, both in commercial and residential, if we could just somehow get all of the other issues we are facing settled."

Issue No. 1, according to Sanderson and many of the state's homebuilders, is the prohibitive cost of trying to obtain property insurance in a state that suffered more than $125 billion in damages, with more than 30,000 homes significantly damaged or completely wiped out by Katrina.

"You have to have deep pockets to get a house built practically anywhere along the Gulf Coast," says Kim Ford, the program manager for litigation and disaster response with the National Association of Home Builders. "And the affordability and availability of insurance is the reason. Without insurance it's nearly impossible to get the support of a mortgage company or banker."

The insurance crisis isn't affecting only new homebuilding. It also hurts the rental market. Landlords who have been hit with higher premiums have had to raise rents significantly, Sanderson says. "This means many workers who are needed in our local shipyards and casinos cannot afford to rent along the coast. They either find apartments 60 or 100 miles away or they don't work around here at all.

"Either way," continues Sanderson, "it has a decidedly negative impact on our efforts to rebuild."

UNFRIENDLY MARKET

The problem has been made only worse, says Greg LaCost, by what insurers view as an unpromising and, to some degree, unfriendly market in the coastal states. "Even before Katrina, the Gulf Coast was not a great area for insurers because the risk was so high," says LaCost, who is the assistant vice-president and regional manager for the Property Casualty Insurers Association of America.

"There is a common perception that if the reward, in terms of higher premiums, is great enough, then most insurance companies will be happy to do business in practically any kind of environment," continues LaCost. "But that has not been true for the Gulf Coast for several years now. The risks are so high that companies actually lose money whenever any kind of a storm comes along. And that ultimately ends up being detrimental to the rest of their customers across the state or country."

Some insurers have withdrawn from the Gulf Coast, not only because of the high cost of risk but also because of litigation associated with Katrina.

In February the State Farm Fire and Casualty Company, after agreeing to pay about $80 million to more than 600 policyholders who sued over Katrina damages, announced it would not renew coverage for some 2,500 customers along the Alabama Gulf Coast...