Should State Government Services be Provided by the Private Sector on a Contract Basis?

PositionPoint Counterpoint - Brief Article - Column

Douglas Richins

yes Utah is consistently ranked as one of the bestmanaged states in the nation. Without a doubt, one reason for this ranking is that Utah successfully partners with the private sector to provide many internal and external government services. These contracts include everything from computer programming and maintenance, engineering and architectural services, janitorial, printing, medical, debt collections, waste disposal, construction and vehicle maintenance.

Privatization frequently increases the quality of services, decreases costs to taxpayers, and helps state agencies focus on those work activities that represent their mission, expertise or skill.

While privatization isn't always the answer, very little harm and usually something very good comes from state management looking at privatizing a function. The mere suggestion of privatization can improve service provision inside and outside of government.

Experience has shown that privatization is desirable when:

* It is likely to reduce cost, be more efficient or improve the quality of service.

* There are multiple firms that can provide specific services.

* Privatization isn't as successful when there is a lack of alternatives and government ends up relying on only one source - competition is an important element.

* Sufficient controls are in place to ensure the integrity of the procurement and contracting process.

* Procurement processes need to be fair and unbiased, and contracts need to be clear and include measurable objectives.

* It eliminates unfair competition by state government with the private sector.

Utah citizens will continue to b better served and Utah's government will continue to be the best in the nation as state government managers utilize the private sector by contracting those areas that business is simply better equipped and more efficient at delivering. These contracting partnerships are a win-win for the taxpayers and state agencies as service improves and costs are reduced.

Dennis Hammer

Sharlene Thomas

no The public sector exists to provide services that are important to the citizens of a specific state or county governmental region, i.e., state, county and local entities. In this regard, the measure of success in providing public service is not weighed by the bottom line but by the number of those served in relation to those who legitimately...

To continue reading

Request your trial

VLEX uses login cookies to provide you with a better browsing experience. If you click on 'Accept' or continue browsing this site we consider that you accept our cookie policy. ACCEPT