Pros and Cons of Voluntarily Disclosing Past Wrongs: To disclose or not to disclose, that is the question.

AuthorAbney, George
PositionTAX COMPLIANCE

Hamlet's thoughts weighed heavily upon him. Should he suffer the slings and arrows of outrageous fortune, or take arms against a sea of troubles? For the young Prince of Denmark seeking to avenge his father's death, the choice was action or inaction, and ultimately life or death. Fortunately, most tax problems do not have such grave outcomes. Seemingly inconsequential tax errors can, however, lead to severe financial consequences. And, remote as it may seem, the prospect of imprisonment for tax crimes cannot be overlooked. When a past wrong is discovered, what should you do? Taking action--voluntarily disclosing the problem to the taxing authorities--can limit your direct monetary exposure tor the specific problem but may have significant collateral consequences. Inaction--sweeping the problem under the rug and hoping for the best--may heighten your exposure if the taxing authorities ever catch on. In deciding whether to disclose a potential tax problem, you must fully consider multiple issues. This article identifies and explores those issues and provides practical insights for those who may one day face the momentous question of whether to disclose or not to disclose.

Something Is Rotten in the State of Bank Secrecy

The era of bank secrecy is over. We now live in an era of international cooperation on tax and financial matters. For national and multinational companies, as well as for individuals, the likelihood that the Internal Revenue Service or other taxing authorities will learn of your tax problems has increased dramatically over the last decade. In a concerted effort to address tax avoidance through base erosion and profit shifting (BEPS), as well as combat willful tax evasion, taxing authorities around the world have been working together to exchange information, seeking to prevent the secrecy that allows income and assets to escape taxation. (1) In the United States, the Foreign Account Tax Compliance Act (FATCA) has placed additional responsibility on foreign financial institutions to share information with the IRS, thus increasing the probability that undisclosed foreign accounts and assets will be discovered. (2) And the U.S. Department of Justice has pursued criminal prosecutions of foreign financial institutions and related individuals, thereby increasing exponentially the pressure to end once common banking practices that shrouded foreign financial transactions in secrecy. (3)

In conjunction with increased disclosure requirements and enforcement efforts, dozens of countries have implemented voluntary disclosure programs allowing taxpayers to disclose tax problems that, in the past, likely would have remained hidden. (4) Encouraging taxpayers to resolve their tax problems by limiting their liability if they come forward and fix problems voluntarily should increase tax revenue and preserve scarce investigative resources. Consider the IRS' Offshore Voluntary Disclosure Program (OVDP). Introduced in 2009, the OVDP encourages taxpayers with undisclosed foreign financial accounts to disclose those accounts by offering a limited lookback period, significantly reduced monetary penalties, and a promise not to recommend criminal prosecution. (5) Since the inception of the OVDP, the IRS estimates that it has collected more than $10 billion in taxes, penalties, and interest from over 100,000 taxpayers, without expending significant investigative resources. (6) Thus, while the chances that a taxing authority will learn of your tax problems have never been greater, governments around the world continue to see value in offering incentives for voluntary disclosures.

That said, not every taxpayer is eligible to participate in a voluntary disclosure program. Inaction upon one's own discovery of a tax problem can lead to ineligibility if certain disqualifying events occur. Under the OVDP, a disclosure is considered timely only if it is made before: (1) the IRS has initiated a civil examination or criminal investigation of the taxpayer, or has notified the taxpayer that it intends to do so; (2) the IRS has received information from a third party (e.g., an informant, other governmental agency, or the media) alerting it to the specific taxpayer's noncompliance; (3) the IRS has initiated a civil examination or criminal investigation which is directly related to the specific liability of the taxpayer; or (4) the IRS has acquired information directly related to the specific liability of the taxpayer from a criminal enforcement action. (7)

Hamlet enjoyed the luxury of ample time to consider his actions. Today's taxpayers do not, and he who hesitates may be lost. Rushing into a disclosure, however, without a full appreciation of potential collateral issues can have disastrous consequences.

Though This Be Madness, Yet There Is Method in't

Will you really confess your tax problems to the IRS? Some would say that to do so is madness. After all, taxpayers are under no obligation to file an amended tax return even if they discover a significant mistake on their original return after it has been filed. (8) And the Fifth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution provides significant protection against self-incrimination. (9) So even if the IRS catches on, it may have a difficult time gathering the information and documents needed to accurately calculate any tax due or prove a violation of the internal revenue laws beyond a reasonable doubt. So why voluntarily confess anything to the IRS or other taxing authorities?

Although it may seem counterintuitive, disclosing a previously unknown tax problem to the IRS may be in the taxpayer's best interest. But the decision--to disclose or not to disclose--is not easy. To make the right decision, taxpayers must fully consider all of the pros and cons.

To Disclose: Pros and Cons

PRO: AVOIDING HARSH CONSEQUENCES OF DISCOVERY

The IRS and other taxing authorities typically...

To continue reading

Request your trial

VLEX uses login cookies to provide you with a better browsing experience. If you click on 'Accept' or continue browsing this site we consider that you accept our cookie policy. ACCEPT