Return preparer's advice does not prevent accuracy-related penalty.

• Author: Keenan, John

It is very common for taxpayers to seek tax return preparation advice and services from a tax professional. If it is ultimately determined that there are errors in the tax return, a taxpayer may incur an accuracy-related penalty under Sec. 6662(a). While reliance upon the advice of a tax professional may allow a taxpayer to avoid a penalty based upon reasonable cause, such reliance is not an absolute defense to

the accuracy-related penalty. In a recent decision, the Tax Court partially upheld accuracy-related penalties against a taxpayer because it failed to reasonably rely in good faith on advice from its tax return preparer (January Transport Inc., T.C. Memo. 2008-268).

January Transport

In January Transport, the taxpayer hired an accounting firm to provide bookkeeping, financial statement, and tax return preparation services. In April 2002, the taxpayer bought a used Cessna airplane. During this same time period, the taxpayer read an article titled "30% Immediate Bonus Depreciation for New and Used Aircraft Approved by House Ways and Means Committee: Anticipated Passage into Law Within Two Weeks." An accountant at the firm had initially warned the taxpayer that bonus depreciation was not available for used assets. However, after the taxpayer shared the article with the accountant, they decided to claim bonus depreciation on the used Cessna. The Job Creation and Workers Assistance Act, P.L. 107-147, which was enacted in March 2002, months after the article was written, allowed for bonus depreciation on certain original use assets or new assets but not on used assets.

Upon examination of the taxpayer's tax return, the IRS adjusted various items reflected on the return. One such adjustment was to disallow the bonus depreciation on the Cessna claimed by the taxpayer. Although the taxpayer agreed to the IRS's adjustments, the taxpayer challenged the imposition of accuracy-related penalties because it believed that it had reasonable cause and acted in good faith.

Grounds for Imposition of the Accuracy-Related Penalty

The IRS imposed the accuracy-related penalty on two alternative grounds. First, the IRS asserted that the taxpayer's underpayment of tax was due to negligence or disregard of rules or regulations under Sec. 6662. Second, the IRS asserted that there was a substantial understatement of income tax under Sec. 6662(d). Negligence includes any failure to reasonably comply with internal revenue laws. A taxpayer disregards the rules or...