Should we elect the president by popular vote? After hundreds of attempts to abolish the Electoral College, opponents are promoting a plan to work around it.

• Author: Koza, John R.
• Position: DEBATE

YES

With the Electoral College, voters in two thirds of states are effectively disenfranchised from choosing the president because they don't live in a handful of battleground states.

Presidential candidates now have no reason to pay attention to states in which they are comfortably ahead or hopelessly behind, in 2008, candidates concentrated 98 percent of their time and money in just 15 states.

Another shortcoming of the Electoral College is that a candidate can win the presidency without winning the most votes nationwide. In fact, the second-place candidate was elected in 2000 (when George W. Bush lost the popular vote to AI Gore), 1888, 1876, and 1824. And in 2004, a shift of 60,000 votes in Ohio would have given John Kerry a majority of the electoral votes, despite President Bush's 3.5-million-vote lead in the nationwide popular vote.

The National Popular Vote plan--which is based on the fact that the Constitution lets each state decide how to award its electoral votes--would solve these problems: It calls for states to award all their electoral votes to the candidate who gets the most votes nationally.

The plan has been passed by eight states (California, Hawaii, Washington, Illinois, Massachusetts, Vermont, New Jersey, and Maryland) and Washington, D.C., and is being considered by the remainder of the states. It would take effect when it is approved by states representing a majority (270) of the 538 electoral votes.

More than 70 percent of Americans say they favor popular election of the president. It's time to make sure every vote in every state matters.

--JOHN R. KOZA

Chairman, National Popular Vote

NO

The Electoral College was a key part of the compromise between large and small states at the Constitutional Convention of 1787, and it has served America well for more than 200 years.

There have been more than 700 attempts to amend the Constitution to abolish the Electoral College; all have failed. The latest...