Machiavelli revisited.

• Author: Drezner, Daniel W.
• Position: Power Rules: How Common Sense Can Rescue American Foreign Policy - Book review

Leslie H. Gelb, Power Rules: How Common Sense Can Rescue American Foreign Policy (New York: Harper, 2009), 352 pp., $27.99.

Richard Neustadt and Ernest May, in their classic work on statecraft, Thinking in Time, tell a revealing anecdote about the early months of the Carter administration. Secretary of State Cyrus Vance and his team were jetting off to Moscow with a secret, dramatic proposal for deep cuts in nuclear weapons by both sides. Vance was filled with optimism about the chances of an arms-control breakthrough. Only one official expressed any pessimism--Leslie H. Gelb, Vance's assistant secretary of state for politico-military affairs. Gelb bet Vance a dollar that the proposal would be rejected without so much as the politeness of a counterproposal. As it turns out, Gelb was right--the Soviets were annoyed by the absence of any advance work and rejected the proposal outright. Gelb left the administration after two years and ended up voting for Ronald Reagan in 1980.

Fast forward thirty-two years. Another Democratic administration is coming to power after a wholesale rejection of eight years of Republican rule. Gelb is now the personification of the foreign-policy community. He was a Pulitzer Prize-winning correspondent and columnist for the New York Times, and followed that with a successful stint as president of the Council on Foreign Relations. He served in two administrations in senior Defense and State Department posts, was director of the Pentagon Papers project and recently advised Hillary Clinton's presidential campaign. Gelb possesses enough gravitas to sink a battleship. Now he has written his magnum opus, Power Rules.

In an effort to avoid seeing history repeat itself as farce, Gelb has penned a "how-to" manual for Barack Obama and his foreign-policy team. He has set a high bar for himself, consciously patterning his book after Niccolo Machiavelli's The Prince. Ordinarily, such a risky gambit is a gift for the reviewer--the author will have inevitably hoisted himself with his own petard, and the reviewer can show off all of the ways in which the book du jour falls short of the famous Florentine's masterwork. Fortunately, in this case the ready critique is not so easy. It is to Gelb's credit that Power Rules is striking more for its similarities than its differences with The Prince. Like Machiavelli, Gelb gets to the nub of hard truths about power and statecraft in a complex world. He tackles how to deal with adversaries, cajole recalcitrant allies and manage domestic rivals in matters of foreign policy. Power Rules misses the mark on occasion--but compared with the glut of grand-strategy books currently in circulation, it is a damned sight better than most.

Power Rules most clearly echoes Machiavelli in its awareness of the linkages between domestic politics and international relations. In his listing of uncomfortable truths, Gelb notes that in one's choice of political allies, "[Moderates] make for weak allies in crises, where the day usually goes to the passionate, ruthless, and most undemocratically...