IADC Amicus Briefs--Volume 88, Number 3.

The IADC amicus curiae program has been active in recent months. The following brief was filed by the IADC since the last Defense Counsel Journal issue:

U.S. Supreme Court Rejects "No Injury" Class Action Under Fair Credit Reporting Act (7/16/2021)

At the end of this year's term, the U.S. Supreme Court issued its ruling in TransUnion LLC v. Ramirez holding that consumers who did not suffer a concrete harm, but rather alleged only a technical violation and potential future harm that did not materialize, lacked standing to pursue claims for alleged violations of the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA).

In this case, TransUnion communicated to a car dealership that Mr. Ramirez's name matched a name on the Office of Foreign Assets Control list of Specifically Designated Nationals with whom business in the United States is prohibited. It then denied Mr. Ramirez credit to purchase a vehicle, embarrassing Mr. Ramirez in front of his in-laws. Rather than sue for his injuries alone, Mr. Ramirez filed a class action on behalf some 8,000 others who were also incorrectly listed, even though most of them did not sustain any injury before the error was corrected.

A federal district court certified the class, and a jury awarded damages to each class member based on Mr. Ramirez unique injury. The U.S. Supreme Court vacated that judgment, stating if a person has no concrete harm, he or she has no Article III standing to sue in federal court. It found that about 75% of the purported class had no standing and dismissed their claims. It then sent the case back to the Ninth Circuit to determine whether Mr. Ramirez was typical of the remaining class members, as typicality is a requirement under Rule 23.

In our amicus brief to the Supreme Court, IADC focused on this issue of typicality, explaining that an atypical plaintiff such as Mr. Ramirez cannot front a class action of people who did not suffer any harm, or at least any harm of the same magnitude. Amicus Committee Chair Phil Goldberg wrote the brief, and IADC joined with the National Association of Manufacturers, Alliance for Automotive Innovation, and American Tort Reform Association in filing it.

Click here to read the SCOTUS ruling.

Utah Supreme Court Rules on...

To continue reading

Request your trial

VLEX uses login cookies to provide you with a better browsing experience. If you click on 'Accept' or continue browsing this site we consider that you accept our cookie policy. ACCEPT