Hate Speech and Persecution: A Contextual Approach

• Author: Gregory S. Gordon
• Position: Associate Professor of Law, University of North Dakota School of Law, and Director, UND Center for Human Rights and Genocide Studies; former Prosecutor, International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda; J.D., UC Berkeley School of Law

!∀!#

Vanderbilt Journal

!∀ Transnational Law

VOLUME 46 March 2013 NUMBER 2

!

!

#

!

!

∀#∃%! &∋%%()! #∗+! ,%−.%(/∃01∗2! 3!

41∗∃%5∃/#6!3∋∋−1#()!

#

#

!∀#∃%∀&∋()∋!%∀∗%+∗#

∋

∋

37&89348!

#

∋ (,−%./∀.&∋ 0%∀1∋ %+∋ /2∀%,32&456##,−∋ ./0∋ −/5∋ 7%,85#∗∋ /.9%52∋

#:,.853;#.&∋ %+∋ 3+,32#9#+2∋ 2%∋ ∃#+%,3∗#)∋ <82∋ ,/5#∋ ./0∋ −/5∋

#52/=.35−#∗∋.3/=3.32&∋7%∀∋/∋∗377#∀#+2∋56##,−∋%77#+5#>∋ 6#∀5#,823%+∋/5∋

/∋ ,∀39#∋ /∃/3+52∋ −89/+32&∋ ?≅ΑΒΧ)∋∆−#∋./,1∋%7∋5,−%./∀5−36∋

∀#∃/∀∗3+∃∋ 2−35∋ ,∀39#∋ 35∋ 68ΕΕ.3+∃∋ ∃3;#+∋ /∋ 56.32∋ =#20##+∋ 2−#∋

Φ+2#∀+/23%+/.∋ ≅∀393+/.∋ ∆∀3=8+/.∋ 7%∀∋ Γ0/+∗/∋ /+∗∋ 2−#∋

Φ+2#∀+/23%+/.∋ ≅∀393+/.∋∆∀3=8+/.∋7%∀∋2−#∋7%∀9#∀∋Η8∃%5./;3/∋%+∋

2−#∋ 3558#∋ %7∋ 0−#2−#∀∋ −/2#∋ 56##,−∋ /.%+#∋ ,/+∋ 5#∀;#∋ /5∋ /+∋ ∃%&∋(#

)∗∋(∋7%∀∋≅ΑΒ46#∀5#,823%+)∋∆−35∋Α∀23,.#∋73..5∋2−#∋∃/6∋3+∋2−#∋

.32#∀/28∀#∋=&∋ /+/.&Ε3+∃∋ 2−#∋56.32∋ =#20##+∋ 2−#∋ 20%∋2∀3=8+/.5∋ /+∗∋

,%+,.8∗3+∃∋ 2−/2∋ −/2#∋ 56##,−∋ /.%+#∋ 9/&∋ =#∋ 2−#∋ =/535∋ 7%∀∋ ≅ΑΒ4

6#∀5#,823%+∋ ,−/∀∃#5)∋ Ι3∀52ϑ∋ 2−35∋ 35∋ ,%+5352#+2∋ 032−∋ 6∀#,#∗#+2∋

∃%3+∃∋/5∋7/∀∋ =/,1∋/5∋ 2−#∋Κ8∀#9=#∀∃∋ 2∀3/.5)∋(#,%+∗ϑ∋32∋ 2/1#5∋3+2%∋

/,,%8+2∋2−#∋≅ΑΒ∋ ∀#Λ83∀#9#+2∋2−/2∋2−#∋56##,−∋ =#∋822#∀#∗∋/5∋ 6/∀2∋

%7∋ /∋ 03∗#56∀#/∗∋ %∀∋ 5&52#9/23,∋ /22/,1∋ /∃/3+52∋ /∋ ,3;3.3/+∋

6%68./23%+)∋∆−3∀∗ϑ∋2−#∋ ∗#7#+∗/+2∋9852∋=#∋ /0/∀#∋2−/2∋−35∋ 56##,−∋

#######################################################################################################################

##∗#+((,%−∃&∗#.),/∗((,)#,/#0∃12#34−5∗)(−&6#,/#7,)&8#9∃:,&∃#;%8,,<#,/#0∃12#∃4=#

9−)∗%&,)2# 379# >∗4&∗)# /,)# ?∋≅∃4# Α−Β8&(# ∃4=# Χ∗4,%−=∗# ;&∋=−∗(∆# /,)≅∗)# .), (∗%∋&,)2#

Ε4&∗)4∃&−,4∃<# >)−≅−4∃<# Φ)−Γ∋4∃<# /,)# Α1∃4=∃∆# ΗΙ9Ι2# 3># ϑ∗):∗<∗6# ;%8,,<# ,/# 0∃1Ι# Φ8∗#

∃∋&8,)# 1,∋<=# <−:∗# &,# &8∃4:# 8−(# )∗(∗∃)%8#∃((−(&∃4&(2#0−<−∗#;%8,∗4∃%:#∃4=#Κ,∋((∃#

7,≅Γ)∗2# /,)# ,∋&(&∃4=−4Β# 1,):Ι# Φ8∗# Λ−∗%∗# ∃<( ,#Γ∗4∗/−&∗=#Β)∗∃&<6#/),≅# &8∗#−4(−Β8&(#,/#

Μ∗5−4#Η,4# ?∗<<∗)2# Η,(∗Λ8#Α−:8,/2# ∃4=# ϑ∗4Ν∃≅−4#ϑ),%:≅∃4Ο?∃1∗Ι# Φ8∃4:(2# ∃(#∃<1∃6(2#

&,#≅6#/∃≅−<62#∗(Λ∗%−∃<<6#≅6#1−/∗2#18,(∗#−4%)∗=−Γ<∗#(∋ΛΛ,)&#≅∃=∗#&8−(#∃)&−%<∗#Λ,((−Γ<∗Ι#

#

304 vanderbilt journal of transnational law [vol. 46:303

35∋822#∀#∗∋/5∋ 6/∀2∋%7∋2−/2∋ /22/,1)∋Α5∋/∋ ∀#58.2ϑ∋32∋ 35∋6∀%=.#9/23,∋2%∋

,%+53∗#∀∋ Μ−/2#∋ 56##,−Ν∋ 3+∋ /∋ ;/,889)∋ Ο+.31#∋ 3+,32#9#+2∋ 2%∋

∃#+%,3∗#ϑ∋ /+∋ 3+,−%/2#∋ ,∀39#∋ +%2∋ +#,#55/∀3.&∋ 3+;%.;3+∃∋ 56##,−∋

/+∗∋ 5398.2/+#%85∋ 9/55∋ ;3%.#+,#ϑ∋ −/2#∋ 56##,−∋ /5∋ 6#∀5#,823%+∋

9852∋=#∋ .#∃/..&∋.3+1#∗∋ 2%∋,%+2#96%∀/+#%85∋ ;3%.#+,#∋3+∋ /∋,%+2#:2∋

3+∋0−3,−∋2−#∋9/∀1#26./,#∋%7∋ 3∗#/5∋35∋5−82∋∗%0+∋ /+∗∋56##,−∋2−85∋

.%5#5∋ 325∋ ∗#9%,∀/,&∋ /+∗∋ 5#.74/,28/.3Ε/23%+∋ =#+#7325)∋ ∆−85ϑ∋ 32∋

5−%8.∗∋ %∀∗3+/∀3.&∋ 5/2357&∋ 2−#∋ ≅ΑΒ46#∀5#,823%+#∃%&∋(#)∗∋(∋

∀#Λ83∀#9#+2)∋Κ#;#∀2−#.#55ϑ∋∃3;#+∋2−#∋52∀3,2.&∋;#∀=/.∋,%+∗8,2ϑ∋/+∗∋

6%553=.#∋ 3963+∃#9#+25∋ %+∋ Λ8/534.#∃3239/2#∋ 7∀##∗%9∋ %7∋

#:6∀#553%+ϑ∋ 35%./2#∗∋ %∀∋ 56%∀/∗3,∋ −/2#∋ 56##,−ϑ∋ /5∋ 0#..∋ /5∋ −/2#∋

56##,−∋822# ∀#∗∋/5∋ 6/∀2∋ %7∋ 3+,363#+2ϑ∋ .%04.#;#.ϑ∋ %∀∋ ∃#%∃∀/6−3,/..&∋

∀#9%;#∗∋%8∃Λ∗∃∋∋;3%.#+,#ϑ∋9/&∋+%2∋Λ8/.37&∋/5∋2−##∃%&∋(#)∗∋(∋%7∋

≅ΑΒ46#∀5#,823%+)∋ ∆−#∋ Α∀23,.#∋ 8.239/2#.&∋ 9/1#5∋ 2−#∋ 6%3+2∋ 2−/2∋

,%+2#:2∋ 35∋ ,∀8,3/.∋ /+∗∋ ,/5#4=&4,/5#∋ /+/.&535∋ 5−%8.∗∋ /.0/&5∋ =#∋

∀#Λ83∀#∗)∋

#

#

837:;!<=!4<>8;>8&!

#

# ΕΙ##Ε7ΦΑΠ93>ΦΕΠ7#ΙΙΙΙΙΙΙ ΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙ ΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙ ΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙ ΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙ ΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙ## !∀Θ"

#ΕΕΙ##>ΑΕΚΡ;#+Χ+Ε7;Φ#?3Κ+7ΕΦΣ#Τ>+?ΥΟ.ΡΑ;Ρ>3ΦΕΠ7##

+79#;.ΡΡ>?ς#ΠΑΕΧΕ7;#+79#9ΡΩΡ0Π.ΚΡ7Φ#ΙΙΙ ΙΙΙΙ ΙΙΙΙΙ ΙΙΙΙ ΙΙ## !∀Ξ"

+Ι## Π∀3∃3+5∋/+∗∋Ι%∀98./23%+∋%7∋≅ΑΒ#Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι ## ! ∀ Ξ "

ϑΙ## ∆−#∋Θ#;#.%69#+2∋%7∋Ρ#∀5#,823%+∋/5∋/∋≅ΑΒ#ΙΙΙΙΙΙ Ι## !Ψ!"

>Ι## ≅ΑΒ46#∀5#,823%+∋/+∗∋(6##,−#ΙΙ Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι # # !Ψ Ξ "

ΨΙ"Φ8∗#Η∋=Β≅∗4&(#∃&#7∋)∗≅Γ∗)Β#ΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙ## !ΨΞ"

ΖΙ"Φ8∗#Ε>ΦΑ#Φ)−∃<#>8∃≅Γ∗)(#Η∋=Β≅∗4&(#ΙΙΙΙΙΙΙ## !Ζ∀"

∃Ι#"Φ8∗#Γ8∃∃38∋≅/5##Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι ## ! Ζ ∀ "

#ΓΙ"Φ8∗#Σ#∗3/∋≅/5##ΙΙΙ ΙΙ ΙΙ ΙΙ ΙΙΙ ΙΙ ΙΙ ΙΙ ΙΙΙ ΙΙ ΙΙ ΙΙ ΙΙΙ ΙΙ ΙΙ ΙΙ Ι## !Ζ! "

!Ι"Φ8∗#Ε>ΦΣ#Φ)−∃<#>8∃≅Γ∗)#Η∋=Β≅∗4&##

#−4#Τ%∀∗35#ΙΙ ΙΙ ΙΙ Ι ΙΙ ΙΙ Ι ΙΙ ΙΙ ΙΙ Ι ΙΙ ΙΙ ΙΙ Ι ΙΙ ΙΙ Ι ΙΙ ΙΙ ΙΙ Ι ΙΙ ΙΙ ΙΙ Ι ΙΙ ΙΙ ΙΙ Ι ΙΙ Ι## !Ζ Θ"

[Ι"Σ8∃#5#∀/∋;)∋≅/+/∗/#ΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙ ΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙ ΙΙΙΙΙΙΙ ΙΙΙΙΙΙΙ ΙΙΙΙΙΙ## !!Ψ"

ΘΙ"Φ8∗#+ΛΛ∗∃<(#>8∃≅Γ∗)#Η∋=Β≅∗4&#−4##

#&8∗#Σ#∗3/∋≅/5##Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι ## ! ! Ζ "

#ΕΕΕΙ##ΑΡ>Π7>Ε0Ε7Χ#Φ?Ρ#;.0ΕΦ#Ε7#ΦΑΡ+ΦΕ7Χ#;.ΡΡ>?#+79#

.ΡΑ;Ρ>3ΦΕΠ7#ΙΙ ΙΙΙ ΙΙ ΙΙΙ ΙΙ ΙΙΙ ΙΙ ΙΙΙ ΙΙ ΙΙΙ ΙΙ ΙΙΙ ΙΙ ΙΙΙ ΙΙ ΙΙΙ ΙΙ ΙΙΙ ΙΙ ΙΙΙ ΙΙΙ ΙΙ ΙΙΙ ΙΙ ΙΙΙ Ι## ![∀ "

+Ι## Ο+∀#5%.;#∗∋Φ558#5#ΙΙΙΙΙ ΙΙΙΙ ΙΙΙΙΙ ΙΙΙΙ ΙΙΙΙΙ ΙΙΙΙ ΙΙΙΙΙ ΙΙΙΙ ΙΙΙΙΙ ΙΙΙΙ ΙΙ## ![∀"

ϑΙ## ∆−#∋(6#,2∀89∋%7∋(6##,−∋/2∋Φ558##ΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙ ΙΙΙΙΙΙΙ ΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙ ## ![Ψ"

>Ι## Β/2#∋(6##,−∋/5∋/+∋+%&∋(#Α∗∋(∋7%∀∋∋

∋Ρ#∀5#,823%+∋/5∋/∋≅ΑΒ#ΙΙ Ι Ι Ι ΙΙ Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι ΙΙ Ι Ι Ι Ι ΙΙ Ι Ι Ι Ι ΙΙ Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι ΙΙ Ι Ι Ι Ι ΙΙ Ι Ι ## ! [ ∴"

ΨΙ"Φ8∗#>+?#≅−/6#/8#ΙΙ Ι Ι ΙΙ Ι Ι Ι ΙΙ Ι Ι Ι ΙΙ Ι Ι Ι ΙΙ Ι Ι Ι ΙΙ Ι Ι Ι ΙΙ Ι Ι Ι ΙΙ Ι Ι Ι ## ![ ] "

ΖΙ"Φ8∗#Ρ<∗≅∗4&(#,/#.∗)(∗%∋&−,4#ΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙ## !ΘΨ"

!Ι"Φ8∗#Η∋)−(Λ)∋=∗4%∗#∃4=#>,≅≅∗4&∃)6##

#,4#;Λ∗∗%8#∃4=#.∗)(∗%∋&−,4#ΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙ## !Θ∴"

#ΕΩΙ##0ΕΚΕΦ;#Π7#;.ΡΡ>?#+;#Φ?Ρ#ϑ+;Ε;#⊥ΠΑ#>+?##

Τ.ΡΑ;Ρ>3ΦΕΠ7Υ_#ΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙ## !∴Θ"

2013] hate speech and persecution 305

+Ι## Ρ%553=.#∋Υ3932/23%+5∋Γ#./2#∗∋2%∋2−#∋∋

∋>8∃Λ∗∃∋∋ς.#9#+25∋%7∋≅ΑΒ#Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι ## ! ∴ ∴ "

ϑΙ## Ρ%553=.#∋Υ3932/23%+5∋Γ#./2#∗∋2%∋(6##,−#Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι ## !∴ Ξ "

>Ι## Ρ%553=.#∋(,#+/∀3%5#ΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙΙ## !∴"

#ΩΙ##>Π7>03;ΕΠ7#Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι Ι ## ! ] Ζ "

#

#

<82∋ 2−#∋ ,−/∀/,2#∀∋ %7∋ #;#∀&∋ /,2∋ ∗#6#+∗5∋ 86%+∋ 2−#∋

,3∀,8952/+,#5∋3+∋0−3,−∋32∋35∋∗%+#)∋

α#3Ι;Ι#;∋Λ)∗≅∗#>,∋)&#Η∋(&−%∗#Π<−5∗)#β∗4=∗<<#?,<≅∗(2#Η)Ι?#

#

ΕΙ#Ε7ΦΑΠ93>ΦΕΠ7#

#Κ,(&#(%8,<∃)<6#1,):#,4# ∃&),%−&6Ο(Λ∗∗%8# <∃1# 8∃(# /,%∋(∗=# ∃<≅,(&#

∗χ%<∋(−5∗<6# ,4# &8∗# %)−≅∗#,/# =−)∗%&#∃4=#Λ∋Γ<−%#−4%−&∗≅∗4&#&,#%,≅≅−&#

Β∗4,%−=∗Ι≅#ϑ∋&#Ν∋)−(Λ)∋=∗4%∗# −4#&8−(# ∃)∗∃# 8∃(#∗(&∃Γ<−(8∗=# <−∃Γ−<−&6#/, )#

∃4,&8∗)# ,//∗4(∗# )∗(∋<&−4Β# /),≅# −4/<∃≅≅∃&,)6# 8∃&∗# (Λ∗∗%8# <−4:∗=# &,#

≅∃((#5−,<∗4%∗ς# Λ∗)(∗%∋&−,4# ∃(#∃# %)−≅∗# ∃Β∃−4(&#8∋≅∃4−&6# Τ>+?ΥΙΑ#Φ8∗#

<∃%:# ,/# (%8,<∃)(8−Λ# )∗Β∃)=−4Β# &8−(# ,//∗4(∗# −(# (,≅∗18∃&# Λ∗)Λ<∗χ−4Β2#

Β−5∗4# &8∃&2# −4# )∗%∗4&# 6∗∃)(2# &8∗# Ε4&∗)4∃&−,4∃<#>)−≅−4∃<# Φ)−Γ∋4∃<# /,)#

Α1∃4=∃# ΤΕ>ΦΑΥ#∃4=# Ε4&∗)4∃&−,4∃<# >)−≅−4∃<# Φ)−Γ∋4∃<# /,)# &8∗# /,)≅∗)#

Σ∋Β,(<∃5−∃# ΤΕ>ΦΣΥ# 8∃5∗# &∃:∗4# =−//∗)∗4&# ∃ΛΛ),∃%8∗(# &,# &8∗# −((∋∗# ,/#

18∗&8∗)#(Λ∗∗%8# %∃4#(∗)5∗# ∃(# ∃4#/,285∋ ∀#85#/,)#Λ∗)(∗%∋&−,4#∃(#∃#>+?#

Τ>+?ΟΛ∗)(∗%∋&−,4ΥΙ# Ε4# &8∗# Ζ∀∀∀# Ρ∀%5#,82%∀∋ ;)#Γ8∃∃38Β#∃4=# &8∗# Ζ∀∀!#

#######################################################################################################################

#ΨΙ# ;%8∗4%:#5Ι#34−&∗=#;&∃&∗(2#Ζ[#3Ι;Ι#[]2#ΘΖ#ΤΨΨΥ#Τ/,)≅∋<∃&−4Β#&8∗#δ%<∗∃)#

∃4=#Λ)∗(∗4&#=∃4Β∗)ε#&∗(&ΥΙ#

#ΖΙ# (##ϑ##)∃Ι2# ;∋(∃4# ϑ∗4∗(%82# Ω3.#∋ ≅∀39#∋ %∀∋ Φ+/.3#+/=.#∋ Γ3∃−2>∋ Θ#73+3+∃∋

Φ+,32#9#+2∋2%∋!#+%,3∗#2#[Ξ# Ω+Ι#ΗΙ#Ε7Φφ0#0Ι#[ΞΘ#ΤΖ∀∀ΞΥ#Τ=∗/−4−4Β#&8∗#%,4&,∋)(# ,/#&8∗#%)−≅∗#

,/# δ−4%−&∗≅∗4&# ,/# Β∗4,%−=∗εΥ∆# Χ)∗Β,)6# ;Ι# Χ,)=,42#Σ853,∋ /+∗∋ !#+%,3∗#>∋ Β/∀9%+3Ε3+∃∋

≅%−#∀#+,#ϑ∋Ι∀##∗%9∋ /+∗∋Κ%+;3%.#+,#∋ 3+∋ Φ+,32#9#+2∋Υ/02# Θ∀#;+7Φ+# >0+Α+#0Ι#ΑΡΩΙ#∴∀]#

ΤΖ∀Ψ∀Υ#ΤΛ),Λ,(−4Β#∃#4∗1#(6(&∗≅∃&−%# &∗(&#/,)#=−(&−4Β∋−(8−4Β#8∃&∗#(Λ∗∗%8# /),≅#−4%−&∗≅∗4&#

&,#Β∗4,%−=∗Υ∆# Α,Γ∗)&#?Ι#;46=∗)2# ΜΘ353..853%+#∗∋ Ξ%∀∗5∋Υ31#∋<8..# 25∋</∀1Ν>∋Φ+,32#9#+2 ∋2%∋

!#+%,3∗#ϑ∋Σ853,ϑ∋/+∗∋ 2−#∋∆∀3/.∋%7∋(39%+∋ <313+∗32#!Θ#Χ+Ι#ΗΙ#Ε7Φφ0#γ#>ΠΚ.Ι#0Ι#∴[Θ# ΤΖ∀∀]Υ#

Τ%8∃)&−4Β#&8∗# %, 4&,∋)(# ,/# −4%−&∗≅∗4&# &,# Β∗4,%−=∗# ∃4=# ∃4∃<6η−4Β# −&(# ∃ΛΛ<−%∃&−,4# &,# &8∗#

≅∋(−%#,/# ;−≅,4# ϑ−:− 4=−Υ∆# Η,(8∋∃# β∃<<∗4(&∗−42# 7,&∗2# Ρ8+35−3+∃∋ Ξ%∀∗5>∋Α+∋ Α+/.&535∋ %7∋

2−#∋Κ#,#5532&∋%7∋2−#∋ς.#9#+2∋ %7∋≅/85/23%+∋3+∋Ρ∀%5#,823%+5∋7%∀∋Φ+,32#9#+2∋2%∋!#+%,3∗#2#Θ[#

;Φ+7Ι#0Ι#ΑΡΩΙ# !ΘΨ# ΤΖ∀∀ΨΥ# Τ∃)Β∋−4Β# &8∃&# −4%−&∗≅∗4&#&,#Β∗4,%−=∗#=,∗(#4,&#)∗ι∋−)∗#&8∗#

∗<∗≅∗4&#,/#%∃∋(∃&−,4ΥΙ#

#!Ι# (##ϑ∋ #)∃)2# 34−&∗=# ;&∃&∗(# 5Ι# Χ,∗)−4Β2# Η∋=Β≅∗4&2# ;&)∗−%8∗)# ΤΕ4&φ<# Κ−<Ι# Φ)−ΓΙ#

;∗Λ&Ι# !∀2# Ψ[∴Υ2# ∀#6∀3+2#∗∋ 3+# ∴# ⊥ΙΑΙ9Ι# ∴2# Ψ∴Ψϕ∴!# ΤΨ[∴Υ# Τ%,45−%&−4Β# ;&)∗−%8∗)# /,)#

δ>)−≅∗(#∃Β∃−4(&# ?∋≅∃4−&6ε# ∃&# &8∗# 7∋)∗≅Γ∋)Β# Φ)−∃<(# Γ∗%∃∋(∗# 8∗# Λ∋Γ<−(8∗ =#δ( Λ∗∗%8∗(#

∃4=#∃)&−%<∗(# 1∗ ∗:# ∃/&∗)# 1∗∗:2#≅,4&8# ∃/&∗)# ≅,4&82# −4/∗ %&κ−4Βλ# &8∗# Χ∗)≅∃4# ≅−4=# 1−&8#

&8∗#5−)∋(#,/#∃4&−Ο;∗≅−&−(≅2#∃4=#−4%−&∗=#&8∗#Χ∗)≅∃4#Λ∗,Λ<∗#&,#∃%&−5∗#Λ∗)(∗%∋&−, 4εΥΙ#

#[Ι# .),(∗%∋&,)#5Ι#Α∋ΒΒ−∋2∋>∃(∗# 7,Ι# Ε>ΦΑ# ]Ο!ΖΟΕ2# Η∋=Β≅∗4&# ∃4=# ;∗4&∗4%∗2#

µµ#ΖΖ2# Ζ[# ΤΗ∋4∗# Ψ2# Ζ∀∀∀Υ2# 8&&Λςνν111Ι∋4−%&)Ι,)Βν.,)&∃<(ν∀ν>∃(∗νΡ4Β<−(8νΑ∋ΒΒ−∋ν#

Ν∋=Β∗≅∗4&ν)∋Β∀Ψ∀∴∀∀ΙΛ=/Ι#