The Guilt of Nations: Restitution and Negotiating Historical Injustices.

• Author: Batista, Deborah Camara
• Position: FURTHER READING - Book review

THE GUILT OF NATIONS: RESTITUTION AND NEGOTIATING HISTORICAL INJUSTICES Elazar Barkan (Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, 2001), 456 pages.

Conducting a thought-provoking theoretical discussion on issues of morality, restitution and practicality, Elazar Barkan examines whether or not restitution for historical injustices has become a significant trend in contemporary international and domestic conflict resolution. Restitution, as he comprehensively terms reparations, restoration, apology and restitution, is an ongoing, arduous and preferably voluntary negotiation process. It is not immune to political power plays and molds itself to accommodate and counter challenges posed by overlapping cultures and traditions, as well as conflicts resulting from the extension of individual human rights to group identities.

The book provides a comparative look at instances of restitution and includes examinations of cases, including German reparations to Jews and restitution for both indigenous peoples and for slavery. Each case is unique and complex, involving different groups, issues, demands, crimes and losses; all are subjected to passage of time, changes in perception and international moral evolution.

Barkan also addresses the challenges of quantifying injustices, historical identities and cultural patrimonies. In considering the plights of Native Americans...