Gideon v. Wainwright.

• Author: McCaffrey, Judith E.
• Position: Letters - Letter to the editor

I thank Bruce R. Jacob for his enlightening and entertaining article, "Fifty Years Later: Memories of Gideon v. Wainwright." Jacob not only reminded us of the importance of Gideon v. Wainwright but shared with us the rare treat of an insider's perspective.

Judith E. McCaffrey

New York, NY

In Florida, approximately 75 percent of all criminal defendants use the public defender. Instead of being the attorney of last resort, the public defender has become the attorney of first choice. Far too many people are using and abusing the system. While public defenders are persistent in seeking increased funding, they are lax in making sure clients are really indigent or in seeking and collecting fees from clients. The legislature passed laws empowering public defenders to charge for the cost of services, then collect those fees through collection courts, liens, or as a probation condition. An alternative for truly indigent clients is an order to perform community service (F.S. [section]938.30(2)) as a condition of probation.

Public defenders could use these tools to reduce the total number of cases they handle. Make...