From the Ford Foundation.

AuthorFarias, Pablo J.
PositionFROM READERS - Letter to the Editor

Mac Chapin's article "A Challenge to Conservationists" (November/December 2004) addresses a number of issues the Ford Foundation has worked on for many years and which we consider key to our efforts to reduce poverty and injustice among indigenous and rural communities around the world. The article raises important questions about the relation of biodiversity conservation and community development. We agree that these matters need to be discussed and analyzed.

However, the article contains factual errors and is generally misleading in the way that it portrays Ford's and other donors' work to generate a constructive dialogue about the development implications of large-scale conservation approaches. First, the article implies that a Foundation-funded inquiry on large-scale conservation and community development is primarily about indigenous peoples and conservation. This ignores the range of issues related to large-scale conservation trends that were examined, and does not capture the Foundation's concern for other local communities--in addition to those of indigenous peoples--which are central to our community-based natural resource management programs.

The article is also incorrect in its depiction of the nature of internal Ford discussion abut the inquiry, particularly regarding the involvement of two Foundation trustees, Kathryn Fuller and Yolanda Kakabadse. The discussion among Foundation staff and trustees, which took place at our regular board of trustees meetings, focused exclusively on the ways we could best achieve the goals of the inquiry. Ford staff drew on the expertise of Kathryn Fuller and Yolanda Kakabadse and were pleased with their willingness to promote engagement of their organizations and others in a dialogue that explored concerns about large-scale conservation. Contrary to Mr. Chapin's claim, at no point did either trustee try to suppress the release of the report resulting from this inquiry. The fact is that the report was released last June to the participating donors, the conservation organizations, and other interested parties.

In analyzing the Foundation's...

To continue reading

Request your trial

VLEX uses login cookies to provide you with a better browsing experience. If you click on 'Accept' or continue browsing this site we consider that you accept our cookie policy. ACCEPT