Free and Open Source Software and FRAND‐based patent licenses

Date01 July 2019
Published date01 July 2019
DOIhttp://doi.org/10.1111/jwip.12114
AuthorCatharina Maracke
78 wileyonlinelibrary.com/journal/jwip J World Intellect Prop. 2019;22:78–102.
Ĺ ƐƏĺƐƐƐƐņfbrĺƐƑƐƐƓ
! !$
u;; -m7 r;m "ou1; "o=|-u; -m7
!Ŋ0-v;7 r-|;m| Ѵb1;mv;v
o |o l;7b-|; 0;|;;m "|-m7-u7 vv;m|b-Ѵ -|;m| -m7 u;;
-m7 r;m "ou1; "o=|-u;
-|_-ubm- -u-1h;
ƐķƑķƒ
Ɛ
;uhl-m Ѵ;bm ;m|;u =ou m|;um;| ş
"o1b;|ķ -l0ub7];ķ ķ &"
Ƒ
;bo &mb;uvb|ķ "_om-m fbv--ķ -r-m
ƒ
ু_m; o]bv|b1v &mb;uvb|ķ -l0u]ķ
;ul-m
ouu;vrom7;m1;
-|_-ubm- -u-1h;ķ ু_m; o]bv|b1v
&mb;uvb|ķ uoz;u u-v0uooh Ɛƕķ ƑƏƓƔƕ
-l0u]ķ ;ul-mĺ
l-bѴĹ 1l-u-1h;ŠѴ-ĺ_-u-u7ĺ;7
m7bm] bm=oul-|bom
ু_m; o]bv|b1v &mb;uvb|
m |_; 1om|;| o= 7b]b|-Ѵ |u-mv=oul-|bomķ 0o|_ v|-m7-u7v -m7
u;; -m7 r;m "ou1; "o=|-u; Ő""ő 1-m 0; v;;m -vh; |o
v11;vv =ou bmmo-|bomĺ o;;uķ |_; bm1u;-vbm] uoѴ; o=
"" bm |_; $ v;1|ou _-v ruooh;7 |_; t;v|bom o=
bm|;urѴ- -m7 1olr-|b0bѴb| 0;|;;m "" -m7 v|-m7-u7b-Ŋ
|bom ruo1;vv;vĺ $_; ]o-Ѵ o= |_bv -u|b1Ѵ; bv |o ruob7; -m
o;ub; o= |_; 7b==;u;m| Ѵb1;mvbm] u;]bl;vķ "" Ѵb1;mv;v
-m7 =-buķ u;-vom-0Ѵ;ķ -m7 momŊ7bv1ublbm-|ou Ő!őŊ0-v;7
Ѵb1;mv;vķ -m7 |o v_;7 vol; Ѵb]_| om |_; 1uu;m| 7;0-|; 0
-m-Ѵbm] rovvb0Ѵ; |;mvbomv 0;|;;m vol; o= |_; lov|
ruolbm;m| "" Ѵb1;mv;v -m7 |_;bu bm|;u-1|bom b|_ !Ŋ
0-v;7 r-|;m| Ѵb1;mv;vĺ $_; -u|b1Ѵ; bѴѴ 0;]bm b|_ -m o;ub;
o= |_; _bv|ou -m7 1om|;| o= "" Ѵb1;mv;v -m7 !Ŋ
0-v;7 Ѵb1;mvbm] u;]bl;vķ 1om|bm; b|_ - Ѵ;]-Ѵ u;b; o= |_;
-1|-Ѵ Ѵ-m]-]; o= ruolbm;m| "" Ѵb1;mv;vķ -m7 ruob7;
=u|_;u |_o]_|v om =|u; orrou|mb|b;v -m7 1_-ѴѴ;m];v =ou
|_; bm|;u-1|bom 0;|;;m "" ruof;1|v -m7 v|-m7-u7
ruo1;vv;vķ b|_ - r-u|b1Ѵ-u b; om "" blrѴ;l;m|-|bomv
o= v|-m7-u7vĺ
+)!"
! Ѵb1;mv;vķ r;m "ou1; "o=|-u;ķ "|-m7-u7 vv;m|b-Ѵ
-|;m|v
$_bv bv -m or;m -11;vv -u|b1Ѵ; m7;u |_; |;ulv o= |_; u;-|b; ollomv ||ub0|bom b1;mv;ķ _b1_ r;ulb|v v;ķ 7bv|ub0|bom -m7
u;ruo71|bom bm -m l;7blķ ruob7;7 |_; oub]bm-Ѵ ouh bv ruor;uѴ 1b|;7ĺ
š ƑƏƐƖ $_; |_ouvĺ $_; oum-Ѳ o= )ouѲ7 m|;ѲѲ;1|-Ѳ uor;u| 0Ѵbv_;7 0 o_m )bѴ; ş "omv |7
Ɛ
)
=
v
b
!
Ő
7
-
7
0
|
ľ
v
Ő
v
-
]
7
;
v
7
-
t
|
;
0
1
0
b
Ƒ
Ƒ
1
Ƒ
2.
Ɛ
Ň
$!&$  $*$
)_bѴ; |_; u;; -m7 r;m "ou1; "o=|-u; Ő""ő
Ɛ
7;;Ѵorl;m| lo7;Ѵ _-v 0;;m |u;l;m7ovѴ v11;vv=Ѵ bm
=-1bѴb|-|bm] vo=|-u; bmmo-|bom ŐѴ-1h 1hŝv ş ou|_ ub7];ŝv "u;ķ ƑƏƐƔőķ u;1;m| 7bv1vvbomv bm |_; 1om|;| o=
v|-m7-u7v _-; u-bv;7 |_; t;v|bom o= _;|_;u "|-m7-u7 vv;m|b-Ѵ -|;m|v Ő"vő -m7 ;vr;1b-ѴѴ |_; r-|;m| om;uŝv
bm|;u;v| bm v;;hbm] uo-Ѵ|b;v 1u;-|; - 1om=Ѵb1| b|_ "" 7;;Ѵorl;m|ĺ
"ol; -7o1-|;v -m7 v1_oѴ-uv _-; -u];7 |_-| |_; "" Ѵb1;mvbm] lo7;Ѵ bv bm1olr-|b0Ѵ; b|_ |_; -buķ
!;-vom-0Ѵ; -m7 omŊbv1ublbm-|ou Ő!ő Ѵb1;mvbm] lo7;Ѵ =-1bѴb|-|;7 0 "|-m7-u7Ŋ;;Ѵorl;m| u]-mb-|bomv
Ő"vőĺ ou; ru;1bv;Ѵķ l-m 1ub|b1v =o1v om |_; -0v;m1; o= Ѵb1;mvbm] uo-Ѵ|b;v -v om; o= |_; h; 1ub|;ub- =ou |_; ""
7;=bmb|bomŐvő -m7 |_;u;0 1Ѵ-bl |_-| v|-m7-u7v bm1Ѵ7bm] "" 1olrom;m|v v_oѴ7 0; uo-Ѵ|Ŋ=u;; -v ;ѴѴĺ
-u| o= |_; 1om1;um 1-m 0; -77u;vv;7 0 -m-Ѵbm] |_; Ѵ;]-Ѵ 7;|-bѴv o= |_; 7b==;u;m| Ѵb1;mvbm] u;]bl;vĺ o;;uķ
-mo|_;u r-u| o= |_; 7;0-|; v;;lv |o 0; uoo|;7 bm roѴb|b1v ou 1Ѵ|u;ĺ $_; m-uu-|b; o= _o ! Ѵb1;mvbm] lo7;Ѵv
7bv1ublbm-|; -]-bmv| "" Ѵb1;mvbm] lo7;Ѵv bv o=|;m vrrou|;7 0 |_; ];m;u-Ѵ 1ub|b1bvl o= r-|;m| _oѴ7r ou ;m1ou-];7
0 |_; ;;m lou; _;-|;7 -m7 ;lo|bom-Ѵ 7;0-|; -uom7 |_; t;v|bom o= _;|_;u vo=|-u; v_oѴ7 0; r-|;m|-0Ѵ; -| -ѴѴĺ
v - roѴb1 l-||;uķ b| v_oѴ7 0; mo|;7 |_-| 0o|_ "v -m7 |_; "" 1ollmb| _-; 1om|ub0|;7 ;moulovѴ |o
|_; |;1_moѴo]b1-Ѵ -1_b;;l;m|v o= |_; r-v| 7;1-7;v Ő-rrovķ ƑƏƐƕķ rĺ ƑƔƖőĺ
Ƒ
m =-1|ķ lov| 1oll;m|-|ouv -]u;; |_-|
"" ruof;1|v m;;7 v|-m7-u7vķ -m7 |_-| v|-m7-u7v m;;7 "" blrѴ;l;m|-|bomvķ r-u|b1Ѵ-uѴ bm |_; 1om|;| o= |_;
ľm|;um;| o= $_bm]vĿ Ő-rr ş ;um-;uķ ƑƏƏƖőĺ $_; uor;-m ollbvvbom _-v u;1;m|Ѵ l;m|bom;7 |_; blrou|-m1; o=
v|-m7-u7v =ou bmmo-|bom -m7 ]uo|_ -m7 -Ѵvo ;lr_-vb;7 "" 7;;Ѵorl;m| -v -mo|_;u 7ubbm] =-1|ou =ou bmmo-|bom
Őuor;-m ollbvvbomķ ƑƏƐƕőĺ 11ou7bm]Ѵķ |_; ollbvvbom -vh;7 =ou ľ=Ѵ;b0Ѵ; -m7 ;==;1|b; bm|;u-1|bomv 0;|;;m
v|-m7-u7b-|bom -m7 or;m vou1; 1ollmb|b;vĿ -vvlbm] |_-| v1_ =Ѵ;b0Ѵ; -m7 ;==;1|b; bm|;u-1|bomv bѴѴ ľruolo|;
-m7 -11;Ѵ;u-|; |_; r|-h; o= -7-m1;7 |;1_moѴo] 7;;Ѵorl;m|Ŀ Őuor;-m ollbvvbomķ ƑƏƐƕķ rĺ ƐƑő Ő-rr ş
;um-;uķ ƑƏƏƖķ rrĺ ƐŋƑѵőĺ !;Ѵ-|;7Ѵķ bm - u;1;m| ollmb1-|bom ;m|b|Ѵ;7 ľ";||bm] o| |_; & -rruo-1_ |o "|-m7-u7
vv;m|b-Ѵ -|;m|vķĿ |_; uor;-m ollbvvbom _-v mo| omѴ o|Ѵbm;7 |_; blrou|-m1; o= v|-m7-u7v =ou bmmo-|bom -m7
]uo|_v -m7 1-ѴѴ;7 =ou - 1Ѵ;-uķ 0-Ѵ-m1;7ķ -m7 u;-vom-0Ѵ; roѴb1 =ou "v bm uor;ķ 0| _-v -Ѵvo -1hmoѴ;7];7 ""
7;;Ѵorl;m| -v -mo|_;u 7ubbm] =-1|ou =ou bmmo-|bom Őuor;-m ollbvvbomķ ƑƏƐƕőĺ omv;t;m|Ѵķ |_; ollbvvbom
;lr_-vb;v ľ=Ѵ;b0Ѵ; -m7 ;==;1|b; bm|;u-1|bomv 0;|;;m v|-m7-u7b-|bom -m7 or;m vou1; 1ollmb|b;vĿ -vvlbm] |_-|
v1_ =Ѵ;b0Ѵ; -m7 ;==;1|b; bm|;u-1|bomv bѴѴ ľruolo|; -m7 -11;Ѵ;u-|; |_; r|-h; o= -7-m1;7 |;1_moѴo]
7;;Ѵorl;m|Ŀ Őuor;-m ollbvvbomķ ƑƏƐƕķ rĺ ƐƑőĺ
ƒ
o 1-m v1_ =Ѵ;b0Ѵ; -m7 ;==;1|b; bm|;u-1|bomv 0; bmb|b-|;7 -m7 =-1bѴb|-|;7ĵ $_; "" 1ollmb| _-v 7;;Ѵor;7
- mbt; -m7 ;ѴѴŊ=m1|bombm] ]o;um-m1; vv|;l |o 7;;Ѵor -m7 l-bm|-bm "" -m7 =-1bѴb|-|; u;Ѵ-|;7 Ѵb1;mvbm]
t;v|bomvĺ v b| rovvb0Ѵ; |o r-; |_; - =ou ;==;1|b; bm|;uor;u-0bѴb| -m7 ru-1|b1-Ѵ -m7 1Ѵ|u-Ѵ bm|;]u-|bom 0;|;;m
|u-7b|bom-Ѵ r-|;m| bmmo-|bom -m7 or;m bmmo-|bom -rruo-1_;vĵ
$_; ]o-Ѵ o= |_bv -u|b1Ѵ; bv |o ruob7; -m o;ub; o= |_; -1|-Ѵ 7;0-|; 0;|;;m 1uu;m| ru-1|b1;v bm |_; v|-m7-u7v
;1ovv|;l -m7 1ouu;vrom7bm] -u]l;m|v bm |_; or;m vou1; 1ollmb|ĺ )_bѴ; |_;u; -u; 7b==;u;m| -v o= bm|;u-1|bom
0;|;;m v|-m7-u7v -m7 ""ķ bm1Ѵ7bm] |_; bm|;]u-|bom o= "" bm |_; 7;;Ѵorl;m| o= - v|-m7-u7 ou |_; lou; ];m;u-Ѵ
1om1;r| o= r;m "|-m7-u7vķ
Ɠ
|_; -u|b1Ѵ; bѴѴ =o1v om |_; t;v|bom _;|_;u -m7 m7;u _-| 1om7b|bomv - v|-m7-u7 1-m
0; blrѴ;l;m|;7 -v ""ĺ ;]bmmbm] b|_ |_; _bv|oub1-Ѵ 1om|;| -m7 Ѵ;]-Ѵ -m-Ѵvbvķ |_; =oѴѴobm] r-u-]u-r_v bѴѴ
bm;v|b]-|; m; r-u-7b]lv 1uu;m|Ѵ 7bv1vv;7 0 "v -m7 b|v bm7v|u l;l0;uv -m7 ;rѴou; 1om1;umv u-bv;7 0 |_;
"" 1ollmb|ĺ
Ƒ
Ň
!   "&! "$)!
ƑĺƐ
Ň
bv|ou -m7 1om|;|
ov| o= |_; vo=|-u; 1u;-|;7 bm |_; ƐƖƔƏv -m7 ƐƖѵƏv  ŐƐƖѵƏő -v ľor;mĿ bm |_; v;mv; |_-| b| -v 7;;Ѵor;7 0
1olr|;u v1b;m1; -1-7;lb1v -m7 1ourou-|; u;v;-u1_;uv ouhbm] |o];|_;u -m7 7bv|ub0|bm] u;vѴ|v m7;u rubm1brѴ;v o=
Ƒ
Ň
!
!
Ň
ƒ
79

To continue reading

Request your trial

VLEX uses login cookies to provide you with a better browsing experience. If you click on 'Accept' or continue browsing this site we consider that you accept our cookie policy. ACCEPT