Foreword

• Author: Stewart Edelstein

xxv

FOREWORD

BY RICHARD F. ZIEGLER

It is no wonder that Stewart Edelstein’s students at Yale Law School

have praised the course in Civil Litigation Practice he co-teaches as “the

best, most informative class to take at Yale Law School” and “a wonder-

ful experience.” The supporting evidence is readily found in th is book:

Stewart applies his experience, in sight, and wit to produce an unusual

guide to trial lawyering that is as enjoyable as it is useful.

What does a gr yphon—the creature of Greek mythology t hat com-

bined the body of a lion with t he head and wings of an eagle—have to

do with civil t rial practice? Plenty. The lion and eagle were the top dogs

in their respect ive animal categories, a nd the gry phon was viewed as

the king of the a nimal kingdom, unexcelled in power and authority. But

do not misinterpret the metaphor—it is not intended to embrace those

trial law yers who let their power and authority go to their heads. It is not

about those trial law yers who conduct themselves as if unbridled self-

regard is the key to success. Th is book is not about swagger.

Instead, Stewart explai ns the gry phon metaphor as reinforcing the

key notion that success as a tr ial lawyer requires mastering multiple dif-

ferent skills. Trial lawyers, like the gry phon, are a hybrid of skill set s.

The best trial law yers are not only persuasive advocates but also creative

problem-solvers. Their conduct and demeanor must adjust to the con-

text—one must behave a litt le differently with a jury than w ith a medi-

ator, for example—but one must never, ever descend into arrogance.

Stewart Edelstein has had an env iable, multi-decade career as a civil

trial lawyer by ser ving his clients effectively and eff iciently. According

to the Chambers G uide, based on independent sources, Stewart is a “truly

superb” lawyer. But “swagger” isn’t in his vocabular y.

ede88012_00_fm_i-xxxiv.indd xxvede88012_00_fm_i-xxxiv.indd xxv 2/20/13 4:07 PM2/20/13 4:07 PM