A Federal Statute Protecting LGBT Employees

• Author: Matthew W. Green, Jr.
• Pages: 6-8

!

!

!

ϑ!

!

4)+3≅#&! 4Α! ∃,∗∃6∃∗3−/%! −//∋≅∃,≅! ∗∃%0)∃7∃,−&∃+,! +,! ∋! 4−%∃%! +(! ∋∃)! ≅∋,∗∋)! ∃∗∋,&∃&Α! −,∗?+)!

∋Σ1)∋%%∃+,!−,∗!∋Σ1/+)∋%!#+Β!∋!/−Β!#−%!∗∋6∋/+1∋∗!∃,!∃%!−)∋−!−%!Β∋//

007& !&8(4()15&9%1%∃%(&6)#%(,%+23&/:;?5#≅((−&

!

! Κ,!:χ;Ν2!5∋Β!Θ+)Χ!η∋1)∋%∋,&−&∃6∋!Π∋//−!Ι4Ζ3≅!∃,&)+∗30∋∗!∋![ι3−/∃&Α!Ι0&2!Β#∃0#2!#−∗!∃&!

4∋∋,! ∋,−0&∋∗2! Β+3/∗! #−6∋! −7∋,∗∋∗! %∋6∋)−/! −,&∃∗∃%0)∃7∃,−&∃+,! %&−&3&∋%2! ∃,0/3∗∃,≅! ∀∃&/∋! =ΚΚ2! &+!

1)+&∋0&!∃,∗∃6∃∗3−/%!()+7!∗∃%0)∃7∃,−&∃+,!+,!∋!4−%∃%!+(!%∋Σ3−/!+)∃∋,&−&∃+,!−7+,≅!+∋)!&)−∃&%

4∃//!,∋6∋)!7−∗∋!∃&!+3&!+(!0+77∃&&∋∋ #∃∃!ϑ∃%−!Π+),%&∋∃,!ϕ!∆∋≅−,! Π∋,0#2!%&∋∋(∃)∗+,∗&∗#−,)&./∗

0(∋∃)∗+,∗ &∗%+,)&.1∗ 233∋+&45∃∀∗6+∗ 0∃)∃∋&7∗89:;∗ (?56∀∗ ≅∋+6∃46(+,∀2!88! Ε7 ∆−)Α!Γ

Ε+7∋,! ϕ! ϑ

−7∋,∗!∋! 0∃6∃/! )∃≅#&%! %&−&3&∋%! &+! 1)+#∃4∃&! ∗∃%0)∃7∃,−&∃+,! +,!∋!4−%∃%! +(! %∋Σ3−/! +)∃∋,&−&∃+,2! 43&!

,+,∋!7−∗∋!∃&!4∋Α+,∗!0+77∃&&∋∋!∋∃∋)#∃∃∗()

!

Κ,! :χχΝ2! ∋! [71/+Α7∋,&! 5+,.Discrimination Act (“ENDA”)! Β−%! ∃,&)+∗30∋∗! ∃,! 4+!

#+3%∋%!+(!Η+,≅)∋%%!&+!1)+&∋0&!∃,∗∃6∃∗3−/%!+,!∋!4−%∃%!+(!%∋Σ3−/!+)∃∋,&−&∃+,!η−∋)!−,!&+!−7∋,∗!

∋Σ∃%&∃,≅!0∃6∃/!)∃≅#&%!/−Β%2![5δΙ!Β−%!−!%&−,∗.−/+,∋!7∋−%3)∋!−&!Β+3/∗!#−6∋!1)+&∋0&∋∗!∃,∗∃6∃∗3−/%!

−≅−∃,%&!+,/Α!∋71/+Α7∋,&!∗∃%0)∃7∃,−&∃+,<!!Ι00+)∗∃,≅!&+!Η#−∃! ⊥∋/∗4/372!Β#+!%∋)6∋%!−%!−,! [[βΗ!

Η+77∃%%∃+,∋)!−,∗!Β#+!∗)−(&∋∗!∋!∃,∃&∃−/!6∋)%∃+,!+(![5δΙ2!∋!∗∋0∃%∃+,!&+!7−Χ∋!∋!4∃//!−!%&−,∗.

−/+,∋!−&! (+03%∋∗! ∋Σ0/3%∃6∋/Α! +,! ∋! Β+)Χ1/−0∋! Β−%!/−)≅∋/Α!1)+71&∋∗! 4Α! ∋! 1+/∃&∃0−/! )∋−/∃&∃∋%!

(−0∃,≅!∋!ϑΦΠ∀!0+773,∃&Α!∗3)∃,≅!−&!1∋)∃+∗Η#−∃!η;5∃∗0∃)∃∋&7∗9&.∗>(?56∀∗:(771∗

0∋+Α∗:∃77&∗6+∗ΒΧ∆2/∗(,∗Η)∋−&∃,≅!Η#−,≅∋>!Μ∋Σ3−/∃&Α2!Λ34/∃0!Λ+/∃0Α2!−,∗!Η∃6∃/!η∃≅#&%!89:.98!ΟΓ+#,!

δκ[7∃/∃+!∋&!−/∃,%&−,0∋2!⊥∋/∗4/37!∋Σ1/−∃,%!−&![5δΙ!Β−%!4+),!−)+3,∗!∋!&∃7∋!

−&!Λ)∋%∃∗∋,&!Π∃//! Η/∃,&+,!−,∗! ≅−Α!)∃≅#&%!−∗6+0−&∋%! #−∗!/+%&! ∋!4−&&/∋! &+!∋,∗!∋!4−,!+,! ≅−Α%!∃,!

∋!7∃/∃&−)Α ∀#−&! ∗∋(∋−&2! Β#∃0#! )∋%3/&∋∗! ∃,! ∋!,+Β! ∗∋(3,0&! Ι0&! Χ,+Β,! −%! “Don’t Ask, Don’t

∀∋//2”! %ι3∋/0#∋∗! 7+7∋,&37! and “weakened the perceived political power” +(! ≅−Α! )∃≅#&%!

+)≅−,∃Ζ−&∃+,%!)

0+,%∃∗∋)∋∗!−!7+)∋!(∋−%∃4/∋!≅+−/!−,!&+!&)Α!(+)!−!7+)∋!0+71)∋#∋,%∃6∋!4∃//!∆+)∋+6∋)2!+∋)!0∃6∃/!

)∃≅#&%!0+773,∃&∃∋%!Β∋)∋!0+,0∋),∋∗!−&!+1∋,∃,≅!∀∃&/∋!=ΚΚ!&+!−7∋,∗7∋,&%!Β+3/∗!)∃%Χ!−/%+!+1∋,∃,≅!

it up to “unfriendly changes<”!#∃∃∗ ()

)∋0∋,&/Α!∋,−0&∋∗!Ι7∋)∃0−,%!Β∃!δ∃%−4∃/∃&∃∋%!Ι0&2!Β−%!(−6+)∋∗!∃,!/∃∋3!+(!−7∋,∗∃,≅!∋Σ∃%&∃,≅!/−Β%

#∃∃∗()

!

Ι/+3≅#! [5δΙ! +)∃≅∃,−//Α! +,/Α! 1)+&∋0&∋∗! ∃,∗∃6∃∗3−/%! ()+7! ∗∃%0)∃7∃,−&∃+,! 4∋0−3%∋! +(!

%∋Σ3−/!+)∃∋,&−&∃+,2!−! &)−,%≅∋,∗∋).∃,0/3%∃6∋![5δΙ!Β−%!∃,&)+∗30∋∗!∃,!∋!::9!Η+,≅)∋%%!∃,!899α

Η+,&)+6∋)%Α!%&∃) )∋∗!)∋≅−)∗∃,≅! ∋! −∗∗∃&∃+,! −,∗! ∃&! Β−%! &−Χ∋,! +3&! 4∋(+)∋! ∋! Ψ+3%∋! 6+&∋∗! +,! ∋!

7∋−%3)∋∃,!∋!

Μ∋,−&∋Μ34%∋ι3∋,&!6∋)%∃+,%! +(![5δΙ! −≅−∃,!∃,0/3∗∋∗!&)−,%≅∋,∗∋)!1)+&∋0&∃+,%2!43&! ∋!7∋−%3)∋!

%&∃//!(−∃/∋∗!&+!1−%%!4+!Ψ+3%∋%!+(! Η+,≅)∋%%!−&!∋!%−7∋!&∃7∋ !Ι(&∋)!∋!∗++7∋∗!−&&∋71&!∃,! 899;2!

[5δΙ!1−%%∋∗!∋!Μ∋,−&∋!∃,!89:_!43&!(−∃/∋∗!&+!≅∋&!−!6+&∋!∃,!∋!η∋134/∃0−,.0+,&)+//∋∗!Ψ+3%∋#∃∃∗

?∃,∃∋&77.2! 5+&∋2! Ε∃//∃−7! Μ;&Ε(,?∗ 65∃∗ 0(?56∗ :&4Ε∗ 6+∗ ;(67∃∗ Φ!!1∗ 2∗ ∃)∃Γ(,(,?∗

“Because of Sex” to Include Gender Stereotypes, Sexual Η∋(∃,6&6(+,/∗&,)∗9∃,)∃∋∗!)∃,6(6.2!γΝ!Μ

!

!

!

Ν!

!

Η−/

[5δΙΡ<!

!!Κ,!89:2! Η+,≅)∋%%! −,∗!ϑΦΠ∀.)∃≅#&%!−∗6+0−&∋%! −4−,∗+,∋∗! [5δΙ2!−,∗!∃,! ∃&%! 1/−0∋2!∋!

[ι3−/∃&Α! Ι0&! +(! 89:! Β−%! ∃,&)+∗30∋∗! ∃,! 4+! #+3%∋%! +(! Η+,≅)∋%%#∃∃!

#&&1%>??ΒΒΒ<0+,≅)∋%%!Μ∃7∃/−)!&+! ∋! ∋−)/∃∋)! 6∋)%∃+,! +(!

∋! [ι3−/∃&Α! Ι0&! ∃,&)+∗30∋∗! 4Α! η∋1)∋%∋,&−&∃6∋! Ι4Ζ3≅! ∗∋0−∗∋%!1)∃+) 2! ∋! [ι3−/∃&Α! Ι0&! +(! 89:!

Β+3/∗!#−6∋!−7∋,∗∋∗!∋Σ∃%&∃,≅!Η∃6∃/!η∃≅#&%!/−Β%2!43&!∃%!&∃7∋!&+!1)+&∋0&!∃,∗∃6∃∗3−/%2!−7+,≅!+∋)!

∃,≅%2!()+7!∗∃%0)∃7∃,−&∃+,!+,!∋!4−%∃%!+(!%∋Σ3−/!+)∃∋,&−&∃+,!&,)!≅∋,∗∋)!∃∗∋,&∃&Α#∃∃!()

β,∋!)∋−%+,!−&!−∗6+0−&∋%!−4−,∗+,∋∗![5δΙ!Β−%!4∋0−3%∋!+(!∃&%!4)+−∗!)∋/∃≅∃+3%!∋Σ∋71&∃+,2!

Β#∃0#! −)≅3−4/Α! 1/−0∋∗! −//! )∋/∃≅∃+3%/Α! −((∃/∃−&∋∗! ,+,.1)+(∃&! +)≅−,∃Ζ−&∃+,%! beyond the measure’s

)∋−0##∃∃!Μ!Η+,≅2!λ!α!Ο[Σ∋71&∃+,!⊥+)!η∋/∃≅∃+3%!Κ,%&∃&3&∃+,Ρ!Ο89:_Ρς!Ψ!

Η+,≅<2!λ! Ο%−7∋Ρ2! #&&1%>??ΒΒΒ<0+,≅)∋%%ς! ∀∃∃∗ &7∀+! [∗!

O’Keefe, 9&.∗>(?56∀∗ 9∋+−3∀∗Ι(65)∋&ϑ∗ #−33+∋6∗+Γ∗ ΒΧ∆2∗2Γ6∃∋∗ Κ+ΛΛ.∗8+ΛΛ.∗ ∆∃4(∀(+,2!! χ!Ο∀#∋!

Ε−%#∃,≅&+,! Λ+%&2! Γ3/Α! γ2! 89:Ν2! −6−∃/−4/∋! −&! #&&1%>??ΒΒΒ

1+/∃&∃0%?Β1?89:Ν?9;?9γ?≅−Α.)∃≅#&%.≅)+31.Β∃∗)−Β∃,≅.%311+)&.+(.∋,∗−.−(&∋).#+44Α./+44Α.

∗∋0∃%∃+,?]3&7µ&∋)7ν<09Ν−:(_Ν−χ8∋Κ,! +∋)! Β+)∗%2! 7+%&! )∋/∃≅∃+3%/Α.−((∃/∃−&∋∗! +)≅−,∃Ζ−&∃+,%!

would have been exempted from ENDA’s non.∗∃%0)∃7∃,−&∃+,!1)+%0)∃1&∃+,%![5δΙ!∗∃((∋)∋∗!()+7!

∀∃&/∋! =ΚΚ! ∃,! −&! )∋≅−)∗

∃,∗∃6∃∗3−/%!+,!∋!4−%∃%!+(!)∋/∃≅∃+,!43&!,+&!+,!∋!4−%∃%!+(!+∋)!1)+&∋0&∋∗!&)−∃&%!∋,37∋)−&∋∗!∃,!∋!

%&−&3&∋#∃∃! Ν8! ΤΡΟ8Ρ<!!Accordingly, Title VII’s religious

1)+6∃%∃+,%2!(+)!∋Σ−71/∋2!Β+3/∗!,+&!1∋)7∃&!−!)∋/∃≅∃+3%!∃,%&∃&3&∃+,!&+!∗∃%0)∃7∃,−&∋!−≅−∃,%&!∃,∗∃6∃∗3−/%!

+,!∋! 4−%∃%!+(! )−0∋! +)!,−&∃+,−/! +)∃≅∃,<!![5δΙ2!#+Β∋6∋)2!Β+3/∗! #−6∋!1∋)7∃&&∋∗!%30#! ∋,&∃&∃∋%!&+!

∗∃%0)∃7∃,−&∋!+,!∋!4−%∃%!+(!%∋Σ3−/!+)∃∋,&−&∃+,

Κ,!89:Ν2!∋!ΤΚ+ΛΛ.∗8+ΛΛ.2!Β#∃0#!1∋)7∃&&∋∗!0/+%∋/Α.#∋/∗!(+).

1)+(∃&!0+)1+)−&∃+,%!&+!0/−∃7! ∋Σ∋71&∃+,!under the Religious Freedom Restoration Act (“RFRA”)

()+7!(∋∗∋)−/!/−Β%! −&!43)∗∋,∋∗! ∋!)∋/∃≅∃+3%!)∃≅#&%!+(!∋! 0+)1+)−&∃+,%’!+Β,∋)% !#∃∃∗:−∋ϑ∃77∗=Μ∗

Κ+ΛΛ.∗8+ΛΛ.2!:_Ν! Μ Ο89:ΝΡ ! Ι∗6+0−&∋%! ≅)∋Β! 0+,0∋),∋∗!that ENDA’s −/)∋−∗Α! 4)+−∗!

)∋/∃≅∃+3%!∋Σ∋71&∃+,%! 0+31/∋∗! Β∃! ∋! )∃≅#&%! Κ+ΛΛ.∗8+ΛΛ.!∋Σ&∋,∗∋∗!&+! (+).1)+(∃&! +)≅−,∃Ζ−&∃+,%!

1)+7∃%∋∗!&+!%Β−//+Β!Β#+/∋!∋!−,&∃.∗∃%0)∃7∃,−&∃+,!1)+&∋0&∃+,%![5δΙ!13)1+)&∋∗! &+!1)+6∃∗∋<!!#∃∃!

O’Keefe, ∀−3∋&<!!∀#∋! 0+,0∋),!Β−%! ,+&!Β∃+3&! 7∋)∃&<!!Κ,!−!%3∃&! 4)+3≅#&!4Α! ∋![[βΗ2!−! (∋∗∋)−/!

∗∃%&)∃0&!0+3)&!#∋/∗!−&!−/+3≅#!∀∃&/∋! =ΚΚ!Β−%!6∃+/−&∋∗! Β#∋,!−,!∋71/+ Α∋)!(∃)∋∗!−!7−/∋.&+.(∋7−/∋!

&)−,%≅∋,∗∋)!∋71/+Α∋∋!Β#+!Β−,&∋∗!&+!∗)∋%%!∃,!−00+)∗!Β∃!#∋)!≅∋,∗∋)!∃∗∋,&∃&Α2!η⊥ηΙ!+1∋)−&∋∗!−%!

−!0+71/∋&∋!∗∋(∋,%∋!&+!any violation of the employee’s %&−&3&+)Α!)∃≅#&%#∃∃∗ΒΒΗΜ9Μ∗Ν∗9Μ>Μ∗

0−,∃∋&7∗Κ+Α∃∀/∗!,4<2!89:!⊥ γ_;!Ο[ ∆∃0# ∗∋0∃%∃+,!∃%!03))∋,&/Α!1∋,∗∃,≅!

−11∋−/ ! #∃∃∗ ΒΒΗΜ9Μ∗ Ν∗9Μ>Μ∗ 0−,∃∋&7∗ Κ+Α∃∀/∗ !,4<2! 5+:α.8Ν8Ν!Οα!Η∃)<2! (∃/∋∗! β0& :_2!

89:αΡ

Τ,/∃Χ∋![5δΙ2!∋![ι3−/∃&Α!Ι0&!∋Σ1)∋%%/Α!1)+6∃∗∋∗!−&!η⊥ηΙ!“%#−//!,+&!1)+6∃∗∋!−!0/−∃7!

(+)!0#−//∋,≅∃,≅!∋!−11/∃0−&∃+,!+)!∋,(+)0∋7∋,&!+(!ο∀∃&/∋!=ΚΚπ<”!!

Μ! Η+,≅! Η+,≅

#&&1%>??ΒΒΒ<0+,≅)∋%%∀#∋! [ι3−/∃&Α! Ι0&! Β−%! )∋.

∃,&)+∗30∋∗!∃,!∋!::!Η+,≅)∋%%!∃,!∆−Α!89:;#∃∃!δ∋7%!η∋.Κ,&)+∗30∃,≅!ϑΦΠ∀!η∃≅#&%!Π∃//2!∀#∋!

!

!

!

Ο!

!

Ι∗6+0−&∋!Ο∆−Α!:2!89:;Ρ2! #&&1>??ΒΒΒ)∋.∃,&)+∗30∃,≅./≅4&.

)∃≅#&%.4∃//∀#−&!7∋−%3)∋!Β∃//!(−0∋!−,!31#∃//! 4−&&/∋!∃,! ∋!03))∋,&!Η+,≅)∋%% !#∃∃∗ () ∆+)∋+6∋)2!

3,&∃/!∃&! +)! %∃7∃/−)!/∋≅∃%/−&∃+,! ∃%! ∋,−0&∋∗2!∋,!−&! /∋−%&! −&!∋! (∋∗∋)−/! /∋6∋/2!ϑΦΠ∀!∋71/+Α∋∋%! Β∃//!

#−6∋!&+! 0+,&∃,3∋! &+! )∋/Α! +,! ∀∃&/∋!=ΚΚ!&+! (∃//! ∋! ≅−1! ∃,! %&−&3&+)Α!1)+&∋0&∃+,!−≅−∃,%&!∋71/+Α7∋,&!

∗∃%0)∃7∃,−&∃+,

…&

! Λlaintiffs have long argued that Title VII’s prohibition against sex discrimination also bars

∗∃%0)∃7∃,−&∃+,!+,!∋!4−%∃%!+(!%∋Σ3−/!+)∃∋,&−&∃+,!−,∗!≅∋,∗∋)!∃∗∋,&∃&Α7−Α!−/)∋−∗Α!4∋!(−7∃/∃−)!

with Title VII’s legislative history as it pertains to “sex.” Κ&!4∋−)%!4)∃∋(/Α!)∋1∋−&∃,≅!#∋)∋,+&!

clear what Congress had in mind when it included “sex” as a trait protected by Title VII. ∀#∋!

/∋≅∃%/−&∃6∋!#∃%&+)Α! ∃%!%1−)%∋ #∃∃!%∃∋(6+∋∗ #&=Μ∗:&,Ε/∗ 0#:∗ =Μ∗Φ(,∀+,2!Ν;;! Τ ;2!α_.αΝ! Ο:χγαΡ!

Ο,+&∃,≅!−&!there is “little legislative history to guide us in interpreting the Act's prohibition against

discrimination based on “sex”Ρ !“Sex”!Β−%! ,+&!+)∃≅∃,−//Α!∃,0/3∗∋∗!−7+,≅!∋!&)−∃&%!1)+&∋0&∋∗!4Α!

∀∃&/∋!=ΚΚ ! Κ&!Β−%! −∗∗∋∗! +,!∋!(/++)! +(! ∋!Ψ+3%∋! 4Α! η∋1)∋%∋,&−&∃6∋!Ψ+Β−)∗!Μ7∃! −! =∃)≅∃,∃−!

0+,≅)∋%%7−,2!Β#+! +11+%∋∗!∀∃&/∋! =ΚΚ2!+,∋!∗−Α! 4∋(+)∋!∋! Ψ+3%∋! 6+&∋∗!+,! ∋! 4∃// #∃∃∗() Κ&!∃%!

0+77+,/Α! 3,∗∋)%&++∗! −&! ∋! −7∋,∗7∋,&! to add “sex” Β−%! ∃,&∋,∗∋∗! −%!−! 1+∃%+,! 1∃/ /#∃∃∗

?∃,∃∋&77.!Π+),%&∋∃,!ϕ!Π∋,0#2!∀−3∋&!−&!_._α∋!%∋Σ!−7∋,∗7∋,&2!,∋∃∋)!

%∋Σ3−/!+)∃∋,&−&∃+,! ,+)!≅∋,∗∋)! ∃∗∋,&∃&Α!Β−%!∋6∋)! 7∋,&∃+,∋∗ !#∃∃∗ ∃Μ?Μ/!Κ Η−1∋)%2!#∃ΟΠ−&7∗

Η∋(∃,6&6(+,Θ∗ &,)∗ ;(67∃∗ Φ!!, 91 Colum. L. Rev. 1158, 1168 (1991) (“5+∃,≅!∃,! ∋ ! /∋≅∃%/−&∃6∋!

history suggests that Congress considered whether the word “sex” encompassed sexuality or

sexual practices”); ∀∃∃∗&7∀+∗ Κ+77+ϑ&.∗=Μ∗ 2∋65−∋∗2,)∃∋∀∃,∗ Ν∗<2! αα! ⊥<8∗!αχ2! αα8.α_!Οχ! Η∃)

:χ;;Ρ!+=∃∋∋−7∃)∗Λ.∗#45ϑ∃,4Ε∗=Μ∗Κ&∋6Γ+∋)2!89Ν!⊥<_ class="_ _0">Οχ!Η∃)+,0/3∗∃,≅!−&!

∀∃&/∋!=ΚΚ’s legislative history demonstrates that Congress did not inten∗!to include “transsexuals”

within the prohibition of discrimination “because of sex”).!!!

δ+∋%!∋!(−∃/3)∋!+(!7∋74∋)%!+(!Η+,≅)∋%%!&+!3&&∋)!∋!Β+)∗%!%∋Σ3−/!+)∃∋,&−&∃+,2!&)−,%≅∋,∗∋)!

+)!≅∋,∗∋)!∃∗∋,&∃&Α!,∋0∋%%−)∃/Α!7∋−,!−&!+%∋!&)−∃&%!(−//!+3&%∃∗∋!∋!scope of Title VII’s 1)+#∃4∃&∃+,!

+(! “discrimination because of sex?” [−)/Α! 0+3)&%! 3,∃6∋)%−//Α! −,%Β∋)∋∗! −&! ι3∋%&∃+,! ∃,! ∋!

−((∃)7−&∃6∋

∃,∗∋∋∗!1)+&∋0&! ∃,∗∃6∃∗3−/%! ()+7!∗∃%0)∃7∃,−&∃+,! +,! ∋%∋!4−%∋%! −/+3≅#! −&!1+%∃&∃+,!∃%! (−)! ()+7!

4∋∃,≅!3,∃(+)7!−7+,≅!∋!0+3)&%!Κ&!∃%!(−∃)!&+!%−Α!−&!∋!/−Β!∃,!∃%!−)∋−!∃%!∋6+/6∃,≅(+//+Β∃,≅!

7−&∋)∃−/%!∋Σ1/+)∋!∋!73)ΧΑ!/∋≅−/!/−,∗%0−1∋

!

& &