Early India from the Origins to A.D. 1300.

AuthorRocher, Ludo
PositionBook review

Early India from the Origins to A.D. 1300. By ROMILA THAPAR. Berkeley and Los Angeles: UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA PRESS, 2002. Pp. xxx + 556, maps, figs. $18.95.

Romila Thapar's A History of India, vol. 1, was published by Penguin Books in 1966. Nearly forty years later that "book, written when one had just been initiated into the profession, now being revised late in life, has elements of an autobiography" (p. xvii). This solemn declaration has tempted me to engage in some form of parallel reading, keeping both editions open in front of me and noting some of the correspondences and differences. This review reflects the notes I took in the process.

Basically, the new volume is a re-edition of the 1966 text: as Romila Thapar notes, it "retain[s] some of the older arguments where they are still relevant" (p. ix). More than that, large sections of the book run parallel to the sequence adopted in the earlier volume: numerous successive paragraphs start with identical or only slightly rewritten sentences (most often developed in greater detail in 2002 than in 1966). Speaking of similarities, I may as well add here, that both editions eschew footnotes: even the sparse footnotes of the earlier text have been either eliminated or integrated in the new text.

On the other hand, the 2002 volume is very different from its predecessor, far beyond the obvious difference that the text fills close to two hundred more (and larger) pages than those devoted to the corresponding time period in 1966. In the first place, when A History of India, vol. 1 was written, Percival Spear's companion volume two (1965) dealing with the Mughal and British periods was already available in print. Consequently, the last three chapters in Thapar's first volume (1966: 266-336) had to carry the history of India up to the year 1526. "A major amendment" has been made to that in the present volume: "I have finally persuaded Penguin that the history of India should be covered in three volumes and not be restricted to two" (p. ix; the new text is "[p]ublished by arrangement with Allen Lane, The Penguin Press"). Early India now closes around the year 1300. The period between 1300 and 1800, which suffered from being divided between Thapar's and Spear's books, is now to be treated in its own right in a separate volume, and a third volume will deal with the period from 1800 to the present.

Second, the distance of thirty-six years from the earlier text allows the author to look back and zero in on two distinct elements: at least twice (pp. ix, xvii) she refers to "new data"/"some new data" on the one hand, and to "fresh interpretations of the known data" on the other. A combination of these two has resulted in "substantial changes in the readings of early Indian history" (p. xvii), a process in which Thapar has been a constant and active participant. Those of us who have followed her writings over the years are familiar with her approach, which she formulates as follows:

My attempt in this book is to treat political history as a skeletal framework in order to provide a chronological bearing, even if chronology is not always certain. This also introduces a few names of rulers as a more familiar aspect of early Indian history. However, the major focus of each chapter is the attempt to broadly interrelate the political, economic, social and religious aspects of a period with the intention of showing where and why changes have occurred and how these in turn have had an effect on each aspect. (p. xxv) In the new volume this objective has been underscored by the introduction of subtitles within the chapters. Whereas in 1966 each chapter ran from beginning to end without any interruption (subtitles appeared only in the table of contents), now more or less...

To continue reading

Request your trial

VLEX uses login cookies to provide you with a better browsing experience. If you click on 'Accept' or continue browsing this site we consider that you accept our cookie policy. ACCEPT