Dodd in the Quad: what the presidential candidates were like in college.

• Author: Frank, T. A.
• Position: TEN MILES SQUARE

Academic achievement in college doesn't necessarily correlate with success in the Oval Office. FDR, for example, was an indifferent student, while Nixon was a brilliant one. But recent history also suggests that a candidate who was a left-leaning Rhodes Scholar in college might make a better president than a candidate who was a right-wing bozo in college. In other words, we can learn something from looking at a candidate's college days.

That's the idea behind the accompanying matrix, which attempts to plot our current presidential contenders according to where they were politically and academically during their college days. Were they strivers or slackers? Were their political beliefs more in line with Karl Marx or Karl Rove? Each candidate has been numbered, so readers who are interested can check out the corresponding explanatory details. Also interspersed in our grid are a few past presidents, for the sake of historical reference. With any luck, this will help readers make a more informed decision--if not necessarily a sensible one.

1. RUDY GIULIANI: Ardently supported JFK (and, later, RFK) and, as an undergraduate at Manhattan College, wrote a column in the school paper calling Barry Goldwater an "incompetent, confused and sometimes idiotic man." By the late 1960s, Giuliani was even farther to the left. Republican Congressman Peter King told the New York Times about getting to know Rudy in 1967: "That summer, there were riots in Newark and Detroit, and Rudy was very sympathetic to the rioters ... He told me he had gone to a bar and started in on a black guy because he wasn't radical enough. Rudy said before the conversation was over he'd turned him into a Black Power guy." Giuliani's academic performance was strong enough to land him in law school at NYU, from where he would graduate cum laude.

2. BARACK OBAMA: Started at Occidental College in 1979 as a less serious student who, according to his autobiography, hung out with "Marxist professors and structural feminists and punk-rock performance poets." Obama's mother worried that he was turning into a "good-time Charlie." Two years later, though, Obama was a diligent transfer student at Columbia University. Obama would later recall his time there as "an intense period of study," during which "I didn't socialize that much. I was like a monk."

3. HILLARY CLINTON: Arrived at Wellesley in 1965 as a Goldwater supporter, even assuming the presidency of the college Republicans in her freshman...