Dealing with Self‐Interest Among Non‐Executive Directors

• Published date: 01 May 2015
• Date: 01 May 2015
• DOI: http://doi.org/10.1002/bl.30017

4 BOARD LEADERSHIP

“Too little liberty brings

stagnation and too much

brings chaos.”

#FSUSBOE3VTTFMM Authority and the

Individual"MMFOBOE6OXJO-POEPO

Q

%FBMJOHXJUI4FMG*OUFSFTU

"NPOH/PO&YFDVUJWF

Directors

by David Gibbs

No director should operate from self-interest whether executive or non-executive.

Here, David Gibbs, Lecturer in Company and Commercial Law at the University

of Hertfordshire School of Law in the United Kingdom, uses the issue of non-

executive directors holding multiple positions simultaneously to open our eyes to

the legal and other complexities involved.

THE LITERATURE ONEJSFDUPSTFMGJOUFSFTU

in the corporate sector is pre

EPNJOBOUMZGPDVTFEPOIPXUIFSJTL

PGFYFDVUJWFNBOBHFNFOUTFMGJOUFS

FTUDBOCFSFEVDFE4FMEPNJTUIF

GPDVTPOUIFOPOFYFDVUJWFXIPJT

UIFPSFUJDBMMZBOEQSBDUJDBMMZSFRVJSFE

UPUBLFPOBOJODSFBTJOHSPMFPOB

corporate board to improve gov

FSOBODF8JUIPVUTVGGJDJFOUVOEFS

standing of the controls on their

TFMGJOUFSFTUUIFJODSFBTFEJOWPMWF

NFOUNBZOPUIBWFUIFEFTJSFEPVU

come. The research described in this

BSUJDMFFYBNJOFTUIFMFHBMDPOUSPMT

BOEHPWFSOBODFJODFOUJWFTPOOPO

FYFDVUJWFTFMGJOUFSFTUUPEFUFSNJOF

JGUIFZBSFTVJUBCMFJOBMJHOJOHUIF

JOUFSFTUTPGUIFOPOFYFDVUJWFTXJUI

the company.

5PDPOEVDUUIJTTUVEZNVMUJQMF

EJSFDUPSTIJQTXFSFVTFEBTBQSPYZ

GPSTFMGJOUFSFTU"OBTTVNQUJPOXBT

NBEFUIBUJGOPOFYFDVUJWFTXFSF

QSPQFSMZEFUFSSFEBOEJODFOUJWJ[FE

BQQPJOUJOHNPSFOPOFYFDVUJWFT

DPVMECFOFGJUUIFDPNQBOZ$PO

WFSTFMZJUXBTBTTVNFEUIBUGBJMVSFUP

IBWFTVGGJDJFOUDPOUSPMTDPVMENFBO

UIBUNPSFOPOFYFDVUJWFTXPVME

simply represent more people reap

JOHUIFSFXBSETPGTVDIQPTJUJPOTGPS

their own benefit at the company’s

FYQFOTFTPNFUJNFTSFGFSSFEUPBT

iQFSRVJTJUFDPOTVNQUJPOw

5PBOBMZ[FUIJTBSFWJFXPGUIF

legal controls and enforcement of

UIFNXBTDPOEVDUFE5IFBOBMZTJT

MPPLFEBUUIFOPOFYFDVUJWFTGJEV

DJBSZEVUZPGMPZBMUZUPUIFDPNQBOZ

as well as potential enforcement

PGUIBUEVUZUISPVHIUIFTUBUVUPSZ

EFSJWBUJWFDMBJNJOUIF6,$PNQBOJFT

"DU1BSU5IFBOBMZTJTUIFO

DPOUJOVFEPOUPBUIFPSFUJDBMBOE

RVBOUJUBUJWFFNQJSJDBMBOBMZTJTPOHPW

ernance controls. The former analyses

DPWFSFELFZHPWFSOBODFUIFPSJFT

BHFODZTUFXBSETIJQBOESFTPVSDF

dependence theory. The latter identi

GJFEQPTTJCMFHPWFSOBODFDPOUSPMT

TVDIBTSFNVOFSBUJPOBOENFBTVSFE

UIFNBHBJOTUUIFBNPVOUPGNVMUJQMF

appointments held in a company by

OPOFYFDVUJWFTXJUIUIFBJNPGJEFO

UJGZJOHXIFUIFSUIFSFBSFBOZTVJUBCMF

HPWFSOBODFDPOUSPMTTVDIBTSFNV

OFSBUJPOPSFRVJUZQBZNFOUTUIBU

DPVMESFEVDFUIFSJTLPGOPOFYFDVUJWF

TFMGJOUFSFTU*UXBTBMTPIPQFEUIBU

FWJEFODFXPVMECFGPVOEPOXIFUIFS

NVMUJQMFBQQPJOUNFOUTBSFBGPSNPG

TFMGJOUFSFTU

Legal Controls

8IFOBOJOEJWJEVBMUBLFTSFTQPO

TJCJMJUZGPSBOPUIFSTJOUFSFTUTUIBU

SFTQPOTJCJMJUZSFRVJSFTUIFTVQFSWJ

TJPOPGFRVJUZVOMFTTTQFDJGJDBMMZ

DJSDVNTDSJCFECZDPOUSBDU The com

pany has a separate legal personality

GSPNJUTNFNCFSTBOEDPOUSPMMFST

CVUUIBUQFSTPOBMJUZJTEFGFDUJWFBT

it does not have the capability to act

XJUIPVUUIPTFDPOUSPMMFST5IFCPBSE

PGEJSFDUPSTBSFUIFDPOUSPMMFSTBOE

UIFZBSFUBLJOHSFTQPOTJCJMJUZGPS

the interests of the company. Legal

DPOUSPMTBSFLOPXOBTiGJEVDJBSZw

DPOUSPMTBOEBTGJEVDJBSJFTEJSFDUPST

NVTUCFMPZBMUPUIFJOUFSFTUTPGUIF

DPNQBOZ-PZBMUZJTBOPOFSPVTEVUZ

BTJUSFRVJSFTUIFTVTQFOTJPOPGTFMG

interest.

5IFKVEJDJBSZIBTEPVCUFEXIFUIFS

UIFEVUZPGMPZBMUZXPVMEEFUFSCPBSE

NFNCFSTGSPNQVSTVJOHUIFJSPXO

TFMGJOUFSFTUUISPVHIUIFUBLJOHPG

NVMUJQMFSPMFT5IFFYBNQMFJOCam-

bridge v Makin&8)$

IJHIMJHIUFEUIBUOPOFYFDVUJWFTBSF

OPUOFDFTTBSJMZQSFWFOUFEGSPNUBL

JOHVQDPNQFUJOHSPMFT)PXFWFSUIF

GBDUSFNBJOTUIBUUIBUOPOFYFDVUJWFT

BSFGJEVDJBSJFTBOENVTUSFNPWFTFMG

interest from the performance of their

GVODUJPO*OTIPSUXIFSFUIFDPNQFU

JOHSPMFDPOGMJDUTXJUIUIFEVUZPGMPZ

BMUZPXFEUPUIFDPNQBOZJUXJMMCFB

CSFBDIPGGJEVDJBSZEVUZ

5IFMFHBMDPODFQUPGFRVJUZPS

GBJSOFTTBMMPXTGPSGJEVDJBSJFTUP

EFGFOEUIFNTFMWFTBHBJOTUBDDVTB

UJPOTPGDPOGMJDUPGJOUFSFTUPOUIF

HSPVOETUIBUGVMGJMMJOHUIFJSGJEVDJBSZ

EVUZSFRVJSFTUIFNUPIPMEDPNQFUJOH

SPMFT"OFYBNQMFPGUIJTXPVMECF

estate agents. While not tested by the

DPVSUTJUJTEPVCUFETVDIBEFGFOTF

XPVMECFBWBJMBCMFUPOPOFYFDVUJWFT

BTUIFZEPOPUOFFEUPIPMENVMUJQMF

SPMFTUPGVMGJMMUIFJSSFTQPOTJCJMJUZ

)PXFWFSJUJTDMFBSUIBUJOBOZDBTF

GJEVDJBSZEVUZJTCSFBDIFEPOMZJGBOZ

DPNQFUJOHSPMFDPOGMJDUTXJUIUIFEVUZ

of loyalty owed to the company. The

JTTVFUIFOJTXIFOBDPNQFUJOHSPMF

DPOGMJDUTXJUIUIFEVUZ

FOOD FOR THOUGHT