A chill in the classroom.

• Author: Rothschild, Matthew
• Position: McCarthyism Watch - Free speech

Deb Mayer was a teacher of fourth, fifth, and sixth graders at Clear Creek Elementary School in Bloomington, Indiana, during the 2002-2003 school year.

On January 10, 2003, she was leading a class discussion on an issue of Time for Kids Time magazine's school-age version, which the class usually discussed on Fridays "and which was part of Clear Creek's approved curriculum.

There were several articles in the magazine that discussed topics relating to the imminent war against Iraq, and one that mentioned a peace march.

According to Mayer, a student asked her if she would ever participate in such a march.

And Mayer said, "When I drive past the courthouse square and the demonstrators are picketing, I honk my d horn for peace because their signs say, 'Honk for Peace.'" She added that she thought "it was important for people to seek out peaceful solutions to problems before going to war and that we train kids to be mediators on the playground so that they can seek out peaceful solutions to their own problems."

Mayer claims in a pending federal lawsuit that the school chilled her First Amendment rights because of this one conversation in class, which she says took all of about five minutes, and that the school district refused to renew her contract because of it. (The quotes above are taken from court documents.)

I spoke with Mayer on January 24--more than three years after this incident took place.

"It didn't dawn on me that people would object to me saying peace was an alternative to war," she says. "I didn't even think it was controversial."

But it sure turned out to be.

"One student went home to tell her parents that I was encouraging people to protest the Iraq War," she says. "The parents called the principal and demanded to have a conference. The dad was complaining that I was unpatriotic. He was very agitated. He kept rising out of his chair and pointing his finger at me."

At the end of the meeting, Mark Hahn, the student's father, insisted that the principal, Victoria Rogers, make Mayer refrain from talking about peace again in the classroom. "I think she can do that," Rogers responded, according to Mayer's deposition. "I think she can not mention peace in her class again."

"I was just floored," Mayer says, "but I said OK because we had a parent out of control, and I didn't want to be insubordinate. I thought that would be the end of it."

It wasn't.

Before the day was out, Principal Rogers had circulated a memo, entitled "Peace at Clear...