De Chatel, Francesca. Water Sheiks and Dam Builders: Stories of People and Water in the Middle East.

AuthorParks, Nadya Hajj
PositionBook review

De Chatel, Francesca. Water Sheiks and Dam Builders: Stories of People and Water in the Middle East. New Brunswick, N.J.: Transaction Publishers, 2007, 207 pages. Hardcover $ 32.95.

In Water Sheiks and Dam Builders: Stories of People and Water in the Middle East, Francesca de Chatel presents a set of narratives that uncovers the voices of people in the deserts of Africa and Arabia where water scarcity or its absence defines people's perceptions. In an effort to illuminate the voices of Arabs, de Chatel conducted interviews with people from many different walks of life throughout Morocco, Syria, Jordan, Egypt, Israel, and the Occupied Territories. For example, she interviewed sheiks, politicians, bureaucrats, engineers, scientists, farmers, and city dwellers in an effort to understand how they connected to water scarcity in the region. De Chatel explicitly notes that her research is not a social scientific endeavor but an attempt to uncover the voices of people, who are rarely heard, in the Middle East. Her research provides new insights into the relationship between people and natural resources, like water, in the Middle East.

The main deficiency of the book is that the author could have provided further exposition of recurrent themes that emerged throughout the narratives. Though individuals present unique voices, they echo common ideas and shared experiences with water. De Chatel could have more deeply considered why individuals shared such similar experiences despite living in different socioeconomic and political settings.

Nevertheless, the book is filled with rich findings that I have divided into three general themes. First, the narratives revealed that water is a sacred resource in the minds of Arabs. For example, a political scientist at Cairo University stated that water has great symbolic value in the Koran and, "[Y]ou read about the rivers of paradise, the rushing streams, the fresh bubbling rivers and greenery--it's all about water ... "(24). In an interview in Jerusalem, we learn from a "mikvah lady" that the physical cleansing of the female body during a spiritual bath plays a central role in Judaic faith (30-31). Despite proclamations of the sacredness of water in the region, there exists a gap between people's perception of water and their actual behavior. De Chatel witnesses, "Sudanese taxi drivers washing their cars with a large hose in the scorching midday sun; leaking and burst pipes flooding a street in downtown Cairo...

To continue reading

Request your trial

VLEX uses login cookies to provide you with a better browsing experience. If you click on 'Accept' or continue browsing this site we consider that you accept our cookie policy. ACCEPT