Chapter 6: Family Law

• Author: Ally Windsor Howell
• Pages: 57-74

Family is one of the emotionally charged areas of human life. Humans love

and are deeply protective of their children. They seek to protect their chil-

dren from even perceived harm. They feel a deep sense of betrayal if their

spouse betrays them or even if they perceive such a betrayal.

Emotion clouds judgment. When bias and prejudice are mixed with emo-

tion and familial feelings and attachments, the combination can be explosive.

§6.1 Marriage

A transgender person in transition or even a transsexual after sexual reas-

signment surgery has a personal relationship dilemma: “Do I or don’t I tell

this person I love and care for about my past life as a male (or female)?” If

one tells the other person, he or she may back out of the relationship, which

will only deepen and magnify the sense of fear that comes with being “dif-

ferent.” If one does not tell the other person, and he or she discovers one’s

past later, it’s likely to cause a break up or domestic violence.

Transgender persons have been caught in the same-sex marriage issues

that have been debated so vigorously during the last number of years. Why

would that be? The answer is that even though a person has sex change sur-

gery, the reported court decisions have taken the position that that person

57

Family Law

CHAPTER 6

ABAPub Howell Transgender Final Pass.indd 57 8/23/13 9:47 AM

is considered legally for the purpose of marriage to be the sex assigned and

designated on that person’s birth certicate.

The view of the overwhelming majority of jurisdictions on this issue is

represented by the Littleton case from Texas:

1.

Medical science recognizes that there are individuals whose sexual self-

identity is in conict with their biological and anatomical sex. Such

people are termed transsexuals.

2.

A transsexual is not a homosexual in the traditional sense of the word,

in that transsexuals believe and feel they are members of the opposite

sex. Nor is a transsexual a transvestite. Transsexuals do not believe

they are dressing in the opposite sex’s clothes. They believe they are

dressing in their own sex’s clothes.

3. Christie Littleton is a transsexual.

4.

Through surgery and hormones, a transsexual male can be made to

look like a woman, including female genitalia and breasts. Transsexual

medical treatment, however, does not create the internal sexual organs

of a woman (except for the vaginal canal). There is no womb, cervix,

or ovaries in the postoperative transsexual female.

5.

The male chromosomes do not change with either hormonal treatment

or sex reassignment surgery. Biologically a postoperative female trans-

sexual is still a male.

6.

The evidence fully supports that Christie Littleton, born male, wants

and believes herself to be a woman. She has made every conceivable

effort to make herself a female, including a surgery that would make

most males pale and perspire to contemplate.

7.

Some physicians would consider Christie a female; other physicians

would consider her still a male. Her female anatomy, however, is all

man-made. The body that Christie inhabits is a male body in all aspects

other than what the physicians have supplied.1

1. Littleton v. Prange, 9 S.W.3d 223, 230–231 (Tex.App. 1999), rev. den. (Tex. 2000),

cert. den. 531 U.S. 872, 121 S.Ct. 174, 148 L.Ed. 2d 119 (2000).

TRA NSGENDER PERSON S AND THE L AW58

ABAPub Howell Transgender Final Pass.indd 58 8/23/13 9:47 AM