1991 Update on Workers' Compensation Law

Publication year1991
Pages2223
CitationVol. 11 No. 1991 Pg. 2223
20 Colo.Law. 2223
Colorado Lawyer
1991.

1991, November, Pg. 2223. 1991 Update on Workers' Compensation Law




2223


1991 Update on Workers' Compensation Law

by John G. Salmon and Francine R. Salazar

This article summarizes the legislative changes in worker's compensation law enacted by the 61st Colorado General Assembly. The article provides a general overview, rather than a detailed analysis. Readers also are encouraged to review the article entitled "1991 Update on Colorado Tort Reform," which appeared at page 2011 in the October 1991 issue of The Colorado Lawyer. That article covered significant legislative changes enacted since September 1990 in general tort law.

Important topics in the worker's compensation area which are covered in this article include, among other things: the redefining of "maximum medical improvement"; the introduction of "medical treatment guidelines"; the imposition of award limitations of $60,000 for permanent partial disability resulting in a 25 percent or less impairment, and $120,000 for permanent partial disability resulting in impairment greater than 25 percent; the ineligibility of injured workers to collect permanent total disability benefits if they are able to earn any wages from any employment regardless of its suitability; the abolishment of claims of "whole person disability" (injury claims must be presented as a specific injury pursuant to the disability schedule or as a physical impairment under the AMA guidelines); the limited exclusion from liability for entities responsible for job placement of individuals participating in vocational or rehabilitation programs; and the specific provisions to be included in fee agreements in workers' compensation claims, the absence of which renders the fee


agreement unenforceable and a violation of the Code of Professional Responsibility

THE 1991 COLORADO WORKERS' COMPENSATION ACT

1. Senate Bill 218

2. Amends: CRS §§ 8-1-102(2); 8-40-102; 8-40-201(4), (5), (8), (12), (15), and (19); 8-41-301(2); 8-41-304(1); 8-41-402; 8-42-101(1)(b) and (3); 8-42-102(2)(c) and (2)(d); 8-42-104(1); 8-42-105; 8-42-106; 8-24-107; 8-42-110; 8-42-111(2) and (3); 8-42-123; 8-43-102; 8-43-201; 8-43-202; 8-43-205(1); 8-43-207(1)(e) and (n); 8-43-209; 8-43-211; 8-43-213(1) and (2); 8-43-215; 8-43-301(10) and (11); 8-43-304(1); 8-43-307(1) and (3); 8-43-313; 8-43-315; 8-43-401; 8-43-406(2); 8-43-409; 8-43-501; 8-47-101; 13-4-102(2)(a); 24-1-121(3); 24-30-1003

3. Adds: CRS §§ 8-40-201(2.5), (3.5), (4), (5), (8), (11.5), (12), (13.5), (15), (16.5), and (19); 8-42-101(3)(a)(II), (III), (3.5), (3.6) and (3.7); 8-42-107.5; 8-42-107.6; 8-42-111(4) and (5); 8-43-203(1.5); 8-43-206.5; 8-43-

[Please see hardcopy for image]

John G. Salmon is senior shareholder of Salmon, Godsman & Nicholson, P.C., Englewood, a law firm which emphasizes plaintiff personal injury law. Francine R. Salazar is an associate attorney with that firm. The authors wish to extend appreciation to law clerk Hollie Ranucci, whose tireless research contributed greatly to this article.




2224


TABLE OF CONTENTS

The 1991 Colorado Workers' Compensation Act

Legislative Declaration 2225

Additions and Amendments to Definitions

"Adverse Action" 2225

"Commission" 2225

"Division" and "Director" 2225

"Employment" 2225

"Maximum Medical Improvement" 2225

"Medical Treatment Guidelines" 2225

"Order" 2225

"Permanent Total Disability" 2225

"Wages" 2225

"Mental Impairment" 2225

Director's Powers and Duties 2225

Occupational Disease 2226

Repairs to Keal Property 2226

Prosthetic Devices 2226

Medical Aid 2226

Physician Accreditation 2226

Case Management 2228

Payment of Benefits 2228

Permanent Partial Disability 2230

AMA Revised Guide vs. Senate Bill 218 Schedule 16 2230

Limits on Disability Payments 2230

Premium Dividends 2231

Award for Permanent Total Disability 2231

Burial Expenses 2231

Notice of Injury 2231

Notice Concerning Liability 2232

Mediation 2232

Binding Arbitration 2232

Hearings 2232

Excessive Medical Fees 2232

Sanctions for Noncompliance 2232

Time Schedule for Hearings 2232

Transcripts 2232

Orders 2232

Frivolous Claims and Defenses 2232

Claims Management by the Director 2233

Appellate Review---Jurisdiction and Procedures 2233

Sanctions for Frivolous Appeals 2234

Attorney's Signature on Pleadings 2234

Reopening of Workers' Claims 2234

Penalties for Violation of the Act 2234

Fraud 2234

Penalties for Failure of Insurer to Pay Benefits 2234

Increase in Compensation in Lump Sum 2234

Defaulting Employer Enjoined from Continuing Business 2234

Data and Statistics on the System 2235

Workers' Compensation Rate Changes 2235

Utilization Review 2235

House Bill 1129: Eligibility of Benefits

Definition of "Dependent"2235

Reduction of Benefits for Violation of Safety Rules2235

Lump Sum Payment to a Widow(er)2236

Compensation in Lump Sum2236

Liability Exemption for Job Placement Entities2236

Fee Agreements and Attorney's Fees2236

Corporate Officer May Represent Corporation2236

Constitutional Issues

Discrimination2236




2225



Due Process2237

Age-Based Discrimination.2237

Proof of Disability2237

Attorney's Fees2237

Conclusion 2237

207(1)(o) and (p); 8-43-216(1)-(3); 8-43-217; 8-43-218 8-43-219; 8-43-301(14); 8-43-303(3); 8-43-304(2); 8-43-304.5 8-43-307(4); 8-43-401(2)(a) and (b); 8-43-501(3)(c)(I)-(e)(III); 8-44-111(3); 8-44-113(1)-(6)(b); 8-47-101(2)-(6); 12-32-107(3)(dd); 12-33-117(2)(p); 12-35-118(1)(z); 12-36-117(1)(ee); 10-4-403(6); 13-4-102(4); 24-1 -121(3)(d) (I)-(II); 24-30-1001(3)(a)-(c); 24-34-104(24.1)(g)

4. Repeals: CRS §§ 8-1-107(2)00; 8-40-203(1)(c); 8-40-302(1); 8-42-110; 8-47-108; 8-47-109;

5. Effective Date: This Act is effective as of July 1, 1991, and applies to injuries occurring on or after such date unless otherwise stated.


Legislative Declaration

The legislature hopes that with the application of this new legislation there will be efficient delivery of benefits without the necessity of litigation and that cases are not to be more favorably construed for either the employer or employee.


Additions and Amendments To Definitions

"Adverse Action" is defined to mean that the Director of the Division of Workers' Compensation "has retroactively denied payment of fees, recommended a change in treating physician" or revoked accreditation of a health care provider [CRS § 8-40-201(2.5)(a)]. Effective July 1, 1995, this subsection will be repealed after being reviewed as required under CRS § 24-34-104, which gives the General Assembly the power to review regulatory agencies and their functions for termination, continuation or reestablishment [CRS § 8-40-201(2.5)(b)(I) and (II)].

"Commission" means the Workers' Compensation Medical Care Accreditation Commission, created by CRS § 8-42-101(3.5). Effective July 1, 1995, this subsection will also be repealed after being reviewed as required under CRS § 24-34-104 [CRS § 8-40-201(3.5)(b) (I) and (II)].

Definitions of "Division" and "Director" now refer to the Division of Workers' Compensation rather than to the Division of Labor [CRS § 8-40-201(4) and (5)].

"Employment" now specifically excludes an employee's voluntary participation in recreational activities regardless of employer's connection therewith [CRS § 8-40-201(8)].

"Maximum medical improvement" is the time at which any further medically determinable physical or mental impairment has become stable and no further medical treatment is reasonably expected to improve the medical condition. The possibility that the condition may improve or deteriorate over the passage of time will not prevent a finding of maximum medical improvement. Also, the need for future medical maintenance which will not significantly improve the condition will not prevent the finding of maximum medical improvement [CRS § 8-40-201(11.5)].

"Medical treatment guidelines" provide for evaluation and treatment guidelines for high cost or high frequency occupational injuries to ensure the provision of reasonably priced, appropriate medical care [CRS § 8-40-201(13.5)(a)].

An "order" is any decision rendered by the director or an administrative law judge [CRS § 8-40201(15)].

"Permanent total disability" means an employee is unable to earn any wages in the same or other employment. The burden is on an employee to prove this inability to earn wages [CRS § 8-40-201 (16.5)]. This bill can be interpreted to mean that if an individual can do any work for money, he or she will not be considered as having a permanent total disability [CRS § 8-40-201(16.5)]. To avoid a determination of permanent total disability, an employer could offer the injured employee some menial job. Moreover, the statute does not say for how long the injured employee must hold a job in order to be precluded from receiving benefits. Once an injured employee has been determined to be permanently totally disabled, his or her case may be reopened at any time if it is shown that the employee is earning in excess of $4,000 or shows an ability to return to work [CRS § 8-43-303(3)].

"Wages" has been amended to replace "reportable tips" with tips actually reported to the Internal Revenue Service. Provisions specifying that farm and ranch employees' income be limited to that reported on their W-2s has been deleted as being unconstitutional. The reasonable value of lodging, as well as other benefits received from the employer, is now included when determining wages [CRS § 8-40-201(19)].(fn1)

"Mental impairment" is now the equivalent of the previous term "mental or emotional stress." As a condition of...

To continue reading

Request your trial

VLEX uses login cookies to provide you with a better browsing experience. If you click on 'Accept' or continue browsing this site we consider that you accept our cookie policy. ACCEPT