- Home
- Books and Journals
- Carolina Academic Press
- Understanding Criminal Law (CAP) 2018
- Title
- Chapter 9 Actus Reus
§ 9.09 MEDICAL "OMISSIONS": A DEFINITIONAL PROBLEM
Jurisdiction | North Carolina |
§ 9.09. Medical "Omissions": A Definitional Problem133
Consider this problem. Patient, P, is in an irreversible coma, kept alive by use of a respirator. D, P's doctor, concludes that future medical treatment would be useless, so she turns off the respirator, aware that the effect will be to cause P's imminent death, which occurs.
[A] Act or Omission?
One way to analyze the scenario set out above is as follows: D committed a voluntary act by turning off the respirator; this conduct caused P's death, which is the social harm of murder; D caused P's death knowingly, the mens rea of murder; therefore, the elements of common law (and, doubtlessly, statutory) murder have been proven. As there is currently no recognized legal defense of euthanasia recognized in the United States, D is guilty of murder.
Is it self-evident, however, that D is performing an act, rather than omitting conduct, when she turns off a respirator on a comatose patient? Literally, of course, D's conduct does include the voluntary act of pulling the plug or turning off the switch on the respirator. But does this scenario differ significantly from one in which D fails to turn the respirator on in the first place, a clear-cut omission? From a semantic point of view, the act/omission distinction seems to fail us here. One can as reasonably describe what occurred by saying "D failed to provide medical treatment to P" as by saying, "D voluntarily turned off the machine, causing P's death."
To some it seems morally obtuse for the line in such cases to be drawn on the basis of the fortuity of whether a doctor initially turned on a respirator (and, thus, must turn it off, a voluntary act) or simply refused to initiate medical treatment in the first place. What troubles us about D's behavior (if anything does) is that a doctor, trained to heal others, has chosen—initially or later—to deny future treatment to her patient. The voluntary act of turning off the machine is merely the means of omitting future medical care. Arguably (but not inevitably), therefore, we ought to analyze D's behavior as an omission.
[B] Analysis as an Omission
Even if the act of turning off a respirator or discontinuing other medical treatment is analyzed as an omission, this does not necessarily resolve all the legal issues. A physician ordinarily has a duty to provide medical treatment for her patients; therefore, she could theoretically be held criminally responsible for an omission of her duty of care.
But what is the...
To continue reading
Request your trial- Title
- Chapter 9 Actus Reus
- § 9.01 ACTUS REUS: GENERAL PRINCIPLES
- § 9.02 VOLUNTARY ACT: GENERAL PRINCIPLES
- § 9.03 VOLUNTARY ACT: SUPPOSED (BUT NOT REAL) EXCEPTIONS TO THE REQUIREMENT
- § 9.04 VOLUNTARY ACT: CONSTITUTIONAL LAW
- § 9.05 VOLUNTARY ACT: MODEL PENAL CODE
- § 9.06 OMISSIONS: GENERAL PRINCIPLES
- § 9.07 OMISSIONS: EXCEPTIONS TO THE NO-LIABILITY RULE
- § 9.08 OMISSIONS: MODEL PENAL CODE
- § 9.09 MEDICAL "OMISSIONS": A DEFINITIONAL PROBLEM
- § 9.10 SOCIAL HARM: GENERAL PRINCIPLES
- § 9.11 SOCIAL HARM: CONSTITUTIONAL LIMITS
Subscribers can access the reported version of this case.
You can sign up for a trial and make the most of our service including these benefits.
Why Sign-up to vLex?
-
Over 100 Countries
Search over 120 million documents from over 100 countries including primary and secondary collections of legislation, case law, regulations, practical law, news, forms and contracts, books, journals, and more.
-
Thousands of Data Sources
Updated daily, vLex brings together legal information from over 750 publishing partners, providing access to over 2,500 legal and news sources from the world’s leading publishers.
-
Find What You Need, Quickly
Advanced A.I. technology developed exclusively by vLex editorially enriches legal information to make it accessible, with instant translation into 14 languages for enhanced discoverability and comparative research.
-
Over 2 million registered users
Founded over 20 years ago, vLex provides a first-class and comprehensive service for lawyers, law firms, government departments, and law schools around the world.
Subscribers are able to see a list of all the cited cases and legislation of a document.
You can sign up for a trial and make the most of our service including these benefits.
Why Sign-up to vLex?
-
Over 100 Countries
Search over 120 million documents from over 100 countries including primary and secondary collections of legislation, case law, regulations, practical law, news, forms and contracts, books, journals, and more.
-
Thousands of Data Sources
Updated daily, vLex brings together legal information from over 750 publishing partners, providing access to over 2,500 legal and news sources from the world’s leading publishers.
-
Find What You Need, Quickly
Advanced A.I. technology developed exclusively by vLex editorially enriches legal information to make it accessible, with instant translation into 14 languages for enhanced discoverability and comparative research.
-
Over 2 million registered users
Founded over 20 years ago, vLex provides a first-class and comprehensive service for lawyers, law firms, government departments, and law schools around the world.
Subscribers are able to see a list of all the documents that have cited the case.
You can sign up for a trial and make the most of our service including these benefits.
Why Sign-up to vLex?
-
Over 100 Countries
Search over 120 million documents from over 100 countries including primary and secondary collections of legislation, case law, regulations, practical law, news, forms and contracts, books, journals, and more.
-
Thousands of Data Sources
Updated daily, vLex brings together legal information from over 750 publishing partners, providing access to over 2,500 legal and news sources from the world’s leading publishers.
-
Find What You Need, Quickly
Advanced A.I. technology developed exclusively by vLex editorially enriches legal information to make it accessible, with instant translation into 14 languages for enhanced discoverability and comparative research.
-
Over 2 million registered users
Founded over 20 years ago, vLex provides a first-class and comprehensive service for lawyers, law firms, government departments, and law schools around the world.
Subscribers are able to see the revised versions of legislation with amendments.
You can sign up for a trial and make the most of our service including these benefits.
Why Sign-up to vLex?
-
Over 100 Countries
Search over 120 million documents from over 100 countries including primary and secondary collections of legislation, case law, regulations, practical law, news, forms and contracts, books, journals, and more.
-
Thousands of Data Sources
Updated daily, vLex brings together legal information from over 750 publishing partners, providing access to over 2,500 legal and news sources from the world’s leading publishers.
-
Find What You Need, Quickly
Advanced A.I. technology developed exclusively by vLex editorially enriches legal information to make it accessible, with instant translation into 14 languages for enhanced discoverability and comparative research.
-
Over 2 million registered users
Founded over 20 years ago, vLex provides a first-class and comprehensive service for lawyers, law firms, government departments, and law schools around the world.
Subscribers are able to see any amendments made to the case.
You can sign up for a trial and make the most of our service including these benefits.
Why Sign-up to vLex?
-
Over 100 Countries
Search over 120 million documents from over 100 countries including primary and secondary collections of legislation, case law, regulations, practical law, news, forms and contracts, books, journals, and more.
-
Thousands of Data Sources
Updated daily, vLex brings together legal information from over 750 publishing partners, providing access to over 2,500 legal and news sources from the world’s leading publishers.
-
Find What You Need, Quickly
Advanced A.I. technology developed exclusively by vLex editorially enriches legal information to make it accessible, with instant translation into 14 languages for enhanced discoverability and comparative research.
-
Over 2 million registered users
Founded over 20 years ago, vLex provides a first-class and comprehensive service for lawyers, law firms, government departments, and law schools around the world.
Subscribers are able to see a visualisation of a case and its relationships to other cases. An alternative to lists of cases, the Precedent Map makes it easier to establish which ones may be of most relevance to your research and prioritise further reading. You also get a useful overview of how the case was received.
Why Sign-up to vLex?
-
Over 100 Countries
Search over 120 million documents from over 100 countries including primary and secondary collections of legislation, case law, regulations, practical law, news, forms and contracts, books, journals, and more.
-
Thousands of Data Sources
Updated daily, vLex brings together legal information from over 750 publishing partners, providing access to over 2,500 legal and news sources from the world’s leading publishers.
-
Find What You Need, Quickly
Advanced A.I. technology developed exclusively by vLex editorially enriches legal information to make it accessible, with instant translation into 14 languages for enhanced discoverability and comparative research.
-
Over 2 million registered users
Founded over 20 years ago, vLex provides a first-class and comprehensive service for lawyers, law firms, government departments, and law schools around the world.
Subscribers are able to see the list of results connected to your document through the topics and citations Vincent found.
You can sign up for a trial and make the most of our service including these benefits.
Why Sign-up to vLex?
-
Over 100 Countries
Search over 120 million documents from over 100 countries including primary and secondary collections of legislation, case law, regulations, practical law, news, forms and contracts, books, journals, and more.
-
Thousands of Data Sources
Updated daily, vLex brings together legal information from over 750 publishing partners, providing access to over 2,500 legal and news sources from the world’s leading publishers.
-
Find What You Need, Quickly
Advanced A.I. technology developed exclusively by vLex editorially enriches legal information to make it accessible, with instant translation into 14 languages for enhanced discoverability and comparative research.
-
Over 2 million registered users
Founded over 20 years ago, vLex provides a first-class and comprehensive service for lawyers, law firms, government departments, and law schools around the world.